Halloween WW - Costume Party (Game Thread)

[VoraciousReader]

To me, he just sounds new. Not new wolf. Just new.

[VoraciousReader]

that was supposed to be in reply to Zurvan.

[metsandfinsfan]

fmx is new?

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]
To me, he just sounds new. Not new wolf. Just new.

[/ QUOTE ]

Maybe. I'm not voting him, am I? I'm just trying to get him to post more.

[tarheeljks]

[ QUOTE ]
Books,
Where do I sign up to be a minion?

[/ QUOTE ]

[VoraciousReader]

[ QUOTE ]
OK, so you have 4 opinions

1. OH isn't posting much content (ldo, the sky is blue, and the sun hurts when you stare at it)
2. Mets is trying to figure stuff out
3. Eskimo is trying to figure stuff out (orly?)
4. Herbie is trying to figure stuff out

How can you have a single wolf suspect? How can you have NOTHING else?

[/ QUOTE ]

This is your post. You act like the newbie should know that OH doesn't post much content.

You also act like he should have a whole bunch of opinions, on day 1, when he doesn't know any of the players involved, and the thread has already blown up out of control at a level sufficient to overwhelm any new player.

[wdcbooks]

You two have signed up. I have six minion positions open and one alternate, kind of an apprentice minion position. You are required to have no strong feeling on wolf/vs. not wolf, you can also be a wolf yourself, I don't discriminate. Stand by for instructions.

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]

This is your post. You act like the newbie should know that OH doesn't post much content.

[/ QUOTE ]

This was not my intention - I intended the sarcasm to let him know that OH was always like that, and maybe make somebody grin.

[ QUOTE ]


You also act like he should have a whole bunch of opinions, on day 1, when he doesn't know any of the players involved, and the thread has already blown up out of control at a level sufficient to overwhelm any new player.


[/ QUOTE ]

This is (part of) what he said in response to me:
[ QUOTE ]

I could give you some more of what I'm thinking but I think it'd just be adding noise since the reasons i have for my thought processes might be different than the reasons you'd think I have since we don't share the same level of knowledge. As more happens in this game and we see what happens tonight, we'll have much more information to go on.

[/ QUOTE ]

So, he's thinking more than he's said. But he doesn't want to tell us what that is. What does knowing everybody matter? He can still have an opinion... and an opinion untarnished by 1.5 years of meta is never a bad thing.

I hate people hinting at having suspects/villagers/whatever and not sharing. It really leaves them open to suspect anybody they want later on, and saying "Oh, I've suspected x since day 1, I just didn't say anything".

And, with his concern for not being fully up to date on everybody's meta... if he's a wolf, there's a chance he's waiting to talk to his partner's tonight, to see who he can legitimately say is acting wolfy, instead of their "normal" metagamey selves.

On a different non-contributor:

tarheels - do you have anything useful to add?

[chuckleslovakian]

I may have to start up my church again to oppose wdc and his minions

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
I may have to start up my church again to oppose wdc and his minions

[/ QUOTE ]
I actually had/have a really awesome idea for a role based on your church. I hope I get a chance to use it sometime.