Malloreon II: Return of the Rivan King GAME THREAD

[Zurvan]

Herbie:

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
FCBL is still Mengha, by the way.

[/ QUOTE ]

Hypothetically, if I am Mengha, and I got the message from VR about having another free kill, and the fact that I am on line, being a newbie, I probably would have killed someone. Or maybe not. Maybe I am Mengha?

[/ QUOTE ]
Wolf-chat, n00b. Your teammates would've been all over you, like I am over Sadi for your ridiculous d1 kill (which worked out pretty damn well for you).

[/ QUOTE ]
psst - Zurvan: this is why I didn't want to discuss good wolf strategy day 1 (still a little miffed at you)

[/ QUOTE ]

What don't you get? There's zero downside to Mengha killing yesterday, so it's not like us discussing whether he should or should not kill changed his mind. The ONLY time Mengha would want to save his guaranteed kill is if he could use it to kill the seer. Since he can't, he might as well start picking off villagers D1. And, if you're a wolf, killing shorty is never a bad thing, and nothing the village says is going to suddenly make a wolf realize that.

[shortline99]

oh, and stephen lololol

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
What don't you get? There's zero downside to Mengha killing yesterday

[/ QUOTE ]
One of us is really really wrong and I don't think its me but at this point it doesn't really matter because we have Mengha nailed

[wdcbooks]

[ QUOTE ]
If FCBL turns up villager (which is really not going to happen), I'd say lynch Herbie tomorrow.

[/ QUOTE ]

Posts like this give me dyspepsia, the grippe, and hysterical tremors all at once. Please don't make me decide you are a wolf again.

The thing is that the wolves are most likely not the ones pushing for a villager lynch, if FCBL is a villager. They are quietly voting him and giving lame reasons or no reaons at all for it. Herbie would be foolhardy to stick his neck out like this to try to lynch a villager if he is a wolf. If he is a villager then it is far more likely you are a wolf than Herbie. You are already trying to shift blame for that eventuality.

[Nicholasp27]

the wolves would rather mengha 'waste' a shot yesterday to hit shorty than waste a night kill on shorty...so it worked out well for them

mengha wasn't harmed and wasn't at risk and the wolves didn't lose a night kill

[lastchance]

wdc is right, of course. The thing is, I kinda want to lynch Herbie right now, but I also want to lynch FCBL.

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
actually, i don't like voting fblc right now

herbie is a wolf and should die today

[/ QUOTE ]
You honestly believe that there is a better chance that I am a wolf than FCBL? ZOMMFG JUST SHOOT ME AHHHHHH.

[Nicholasp27]

maybe i missed it...how are we so certain that fcbl is mengha? if so, then of course i'll switch back...

[shortline99]

c'mon wolves HIT ME AGAIN

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
the wolves would rather mengha 'waste' a shot yesterday to hit shorty than waste a night kill on shorty...so it worked out well for them

mengha wasn't harmed and wasn't at risk and the wolves didn't lose a night kill

[/ QUOTE ]
Too bad shorty wasn't the seer. lol. Actually, Mengha for seer trade isn't the worst thing in the world, you're right.

Hmm.. I could be wrong about FCBL here, but please explain [ QUOTE ]

Hypothetically, if I am Mengha, and I got the message from VR about having another free kill, and the fact that I am on line, being a newbie, I probably would have killed someone. Or maybe not. Maybe I am Mengha?

[/ QUOTE ]
to me.