MISH MASH 5: THE SHORTLINENING (GAME THREAD)

[Boiler_bd]

changed my mind on sighing. Probably a pro village role. WDC is definitely on my list though.

so amp/wdc/bobo/ maybe nich (though I just glanced at a few of his posts today like I did with sighing)

[Patton4]

DMB - since Aaron was village, I tend to believe you are village as well

Sighing/Boiler/Luck - villagish

Bluff - village/neutral I haven't changed my mind on this yet

BobO/Zurvan/Durron - I'm concerned with these three...

IY/Zero - 1st instinct=evil I'd be happy with either of these two at this point

I agree with most of what has been deduced about the reasons for last nights killings.

[DMBFan23]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

I was looking to your list for possible inspiration, since the games I've played with you you usually have some kind of uncanny knack for listing wolves there.


[/ QUOTE ]

i'm often better at finding villagers than wolves

[/ QUOTE ]

this was quick reply, right? it wuddn't me

[DMBFan23]

boiler,

as far as I know Hyde doesn't get to choose his kill at this point

[Zurvan]

Boiler

Your conclusions (besides Tokyo) seem to have been pulled out of your ass. There's no reason to suspect that stephen was killed by CN instead of one of the evil factions. Remember, they're trying to kill the other baddies too.

Patton's either evil or incredibly misguided - I haven't decided yet.

[DMBFan23]

also, there's a pumpkin who could have killed either player...do all pumpkin deaths get pumpkin-writeups? if not, there are 2.5 potential sources for 2 night kills, the kyro posts are only useful if you think the evil faction killed kyro (more on that below). I agree with you that Tokyo!! and Stephen H's kills are mostly explained.

If the evils killed kyro, it points to Nich. if the evils killed MDD, it points to Patton/Bluff. meh, flip a coin, they're all wolfy sounding IMO.

[Boiler_bd]

[ QUOTE ]
boiler,

as far as I know Hyde doesn't get to choose his kill at this point

[/ QUOTE ]

correct, kyro is my guess because I dont understand why anyone would target him last night.

I believe Hyde's kills are based on events that take place in the thread such as voting for hyde or maybe hyde defending you etc...basically anyone mentioned by the target, or people who mentioned the target that day. That is why kyro's posts should be looked at for clue's to Hyde's identity. I dont think anyone mentioned kyro's name much yesterday.

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]

If the evils killed kyro, it points to Nich. if the evils killed MDD, it points to Patton/Bluff. meh, flip a coin, they're all wolfy sounding IMO.

[/ QUOTE ]

If the evils killed both, it points to nich/patton/bluff, which isn't a terrible list.

[Boiler_bd]

[ QUOTE ]
Boiler

Your conclusions (besides Tokyo) seem to have been pulled out of your ass. There's no reason to suspect that stephen was killed by CN instead of one of the evil factions. Remember, they're trying to kill the other baddies too.

Patton's either evil or incredibly misguided - I haven't decided yet.

[/ QUOTE ]

I was a big fan of the stephen wagon yesterday and if I was the SK I would have killed him with about 2 seconds of thought. Fair argument though, there is no way to know for sure who killed whom and I may be biased.

[DMBFan23]

Zurvan,

I think this ties in well with what sighing said earlier, where the bad guys are less likely to kill someone who was the prime lynch candidate the next day. unfortunately with multiple evil factions, the unreliability of the seer info this game (once we finally DO get it) and the multiple sources of killings, we have to talk more in terms of likelihoods or probabilites and less in terms of "A therefore B" type logic (to the extent that we can do that in WW in the first place, that is). I guess the main point is that I think that Stephen H had the greatest chance of being killed by CN.

Of course maybe CN will eventually come out, ala Pudley in MM3.