|
View Poll Results: 85s or 56s | |||
85s | 25 | 40.98% | |
56s | 36 | 59.02% | |
Voters: 61. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#51
|
|||
|
|||
Re: delgado for HOF??
his weighted OPS is 1 pt higher. Winfield was more consistent but no black ink so not dominant in any category
I am conceding that Winfield was definitely the better player, but am arguing that it was closer than you guys are giving credit for |
#52
|
|||
|
|||
Re: delgado for HOF??
Jim Rice: 9058 PA, 128 Adj OPS+
Dave Winfield, 12358, 129 Adj OPS+ Rice's OPS+ is artificially inflated compared to a guy like Andre Dawson and Dave Winfield because he didn't play through his decline phase. For example, through Dave Winfield's first 9500 PA, his AdjOPS+ was 134. Also, when you consider Rice was overrated by OPS because of his low OBP, and some of the guys I mentioned were CFs (Dawson, Murphy), he's closer to those guys than Dave Winfield. |
|
|