SLOW GAME: Welcome to the Bay Area (Werewolf, Northern CA edition)

[antidan444]

FYI here's where we stand:

aaron - roundtower
antidan - roundtower
bojtun -
clown -
fcbl -
fnord -
HBE -
MDD - roundtower
mets -
nich - roundtower
roundtower - HBE
soah - stephen
stephen - nich

VOTING ORDER
NICH votes for ROUNDTOWER (1)
ANTIDAN votes for ROUNDTOWER (2)
ROUNDTOWER votes for HBE (1)
AARON votes for ROUNDTOWER (3)
MDD votes for ROUNDTOWER (4)
SOAH votes for STEPHEN (1)
STEPHEN votes for NICH (1)

[antidan444]

Here's probably the best argument I can make for RT being a wolf ...

Middle of day 1:

ANTIDAN switches from AARON (0) to CUEBALL (4)
MDD switches from NICH (0) to ROUNDTOWER (4)
CUEBALL switches from CLOWN (0) to METS (1)

If RT is a villager, why wouldn't cueball vote for him here?

[soah]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
IS there a minimum post requirement?

[/ QUOTE ]

You do need to vote at least once before nightfall (which is a long, long time away).
Lynch Roundtower

and I'm all set.

[/ QUOTE ]

the juxtaposition of the forced unhelpful helpfulness with the subsequent vote to lynch strikes me as being quite strange

generally players either adopt the attitude that they want to help the noobs feel at home, or they just don't care, but here we have both? for now I am going with the hypothesis that RT and Stephen are the two wolves. I will see if subsequent posts rule out this possibility (I'm starting from scratch for the moment).

[soah]

ok, from rereading d1, I don't see how we can not lynch RT. But I'm not gonna vote for him yet cuz you morans will probably make it majority again instead of posting some stuff that we can look back on later.

[His Boy Elroy]

lolololol we are all morans AMIRITE

[His Boy Elroy]

its awesome to be on your team when you call me a moron over and over btw

makes me feel all tingly inside

[soah]

I've decided to rescind the villager point I awarded RT for his cueball voting after realizing that there was a count posted just a bit before night where cue had 6 votes and boj only had 4. No one had voted bojtun after that so throwing vote #7 on there means absolutely nothing. I find it somewhat hard to believe that he wouldn't make any effort at all to figure out the count before voting when it was posted just 10 posts above. Especially since he then says he was making a self-preservation vote, implying a knowledge of the count. And by the time he announces his intentions to stay on cueball, he himself was up to 5 votes. But then he doesn't even stick around for 20 more minutes to see if something happens?

[soah]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say that he got two votes for it because it was pretty [censored] wolfy.

[/ QUOTE ]

Actually, that's not why I voted for him at all. This is his first long game (right?) and I wanted to see what would happen if he caught a vote - less experienced players give more info from early votes than more experienced players.
I'm still deciding what I think of his "don't vote me, i'm a villager" reply.

[/ QUOTE ]

Stephen never changed his vote the entire day... he's saying that his vote on RT wasn't because he found him wolfy, and he's saying he still doesn't have any reason to think he's wolfy... but then when it's closing in on lynch time, RT and mets are the only people he expresses any interest in lynching, and he flip-flops on mets as soon as I write one line about him...

[MDoranD]

well i feel pretty confident that soah is village. I think hes nicer when hes a wolf.

[MDoranD]

im not voting stephen simply cuz hes about the only other person that thinks nich is a wolf