LOTR: Return of the King (GAME THREAD)

[Nicholasp27]

dmk

[Skoob]

I have a question.

If Nich is def a wolf, wouldn't he know who the wolves tried to nightkill?

DMK - you're operating under the assumption that Galndalf was roleblocked and someone else was the attempted nightkill. If Nich is a wolf, he would know who the attempted night kill was. Since it was not successful (the nightkill) then it is safe to assume that aragorn saved whomever the wolves tried to kill.

Why would Nich then lie about protecting Gandalf when he could deduce that someone else would have been protected?

Would that be just a colossal on his part then?

[Skoob]

Edit:
I mean a "colossal blunder" on his part.

[dmk]

skoob,

because then he would be clearing a villager.

[Nicholasp27]

gj skoob

if i was a wolf, i woulda said i protected someone different than aaron to avoid this mess

[Nez477]

[ QUOTE ]
nez, i said why
i'm leaving shortly to go to the game, so i won't be here later

[/ QUOTE ]

Ah, thanks. Not so dumb then.

I need to slow down. Or stop reading during work. One of the two.

[Nicholasp27]

[ QUOTE ]
skoob,

because then he would be clearing a villager.

[/ QUOTE ]

why?

i would say i protected rand(player); could be wolf...

[Skoob]

[ QUOTE ]
skoob,

because then he would be clearing a villager.

[/ QUOTE ]
Okay then why not clear a villager to save your own skin? Or is it better to sacrifice yourself for clearing just one villager?

[dmk]

[ QUOTE ]
yes, he was roleblocked

they then also targetted him, hoping to get him with the 50%...they wanna free up roleblocker for blocking frodo later on...


if there are no corruptibles, then aaron was 100% targetted last night

[/ QUOTE ]

orrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

wolves aren't 100% retarded and roleblocked aaron and went random powerrole hunting with their kill. like any other game we've ever played.

[Nez477]

[ QUOTE ]
nich,

nice try. its over. you must be a very powerful wolf.

[ QUOTE ]
of course they roleblocked him because they didn't want a 50% shot at aaron living with a peek


[/ QUOTE ]

that makes 0 sense. they roleblocked because they didn't want him to have a peek - period. there's no 50% to roleblock. he was 100% roleblocked. which means there's 0 reason to target for kill.

its ovah.

[/ QUOTE ]

DMK,

If Aragorn protects Gandalf (standard here, right?) there is a 50% chance that Gandalf lives. Right?

Ok. Now, if there is a 50% chance that Gandalf lives, whom do you think the wolves should be roleblocking?

I don't know if this charade makes you a villager or a wolf.

Every sane wolf would've roleblocked and tried to kill Gandalf last night.