Demon 2: Dust to Dust - Game Thread

[amplify]

[ QUOTE ]
I firmly believe that lynching VR should be the play of choice today. Amp and GT, do you disagree?

[/ QUOTE ]
Do I understand correctly that the proposal is to protect GT1T tonight instead of me? Sounds stupid.

[kyro]

shortline

I've had it.

[fnord_too]

Right now, about the only person I have a good idea about is spook. I think he is a vanilla villager and I think the DH should follow his advice and kill him if he is forced to kill (and doesn't have a better candidate). If he is the DH, that's fine too. I certainly don't think he is going to get possessed since he is the perfect DH kill if the DH does not have a strong read.

In short, no one but a vanilla villager (or the DH) would say "I'm a vanilla villager, DH kill me at night if you are having trouble finding a good kill" in the first round.

Seriously, if I was the DH I would whack him. A power role or demon would be a fool to say that, since it is unlikely that the DH will have a clean kill tonight (assuming we don't find a demon). (The liklihood we do get a demon is a little higher with the existance of an executioner I think, but still < 50% IMO).

Other than that VR is hate magnate, though I don't really see the reason at this point, shorty and kyro are being annoying, stephen gets a big whiskey tango fox. And I will go back to waiting until I have enough information to make an informed decision.

(Again, the point of this post is to say let spook be the escape valve he offered himself up to be. That is, kill him DH if you need someone to kill, at worst he is exactly what he sais he is and at best he is evil guilty of major FPS.)

[sighing]

[ QUOTE ]
1. The demon hunter can fire bullets into me instead of risking night killing villagers and I wont die under the angels protection (plz clarify Jonsan)

2. The angel will learn who the demon hunter is since I will be targeted for death. This will help fortify the villages power roles and help them not get lynched. (They can defend each other,wont vote for eachother, etc)

[/ QUOTE ]
These options were both already available with angel protection on amplify.

[shortline99]

How about the angel protects one of GT and Amplify and doesn't say which?

[shortline99]

Amplify looks like a vanilla villager. GT says he's a power role. you tell me which needs the protection more.

[sighing]

[ QUOTE ]
How about the angel protects one of GT and Amplify and doesn't say which?

[/ QUOTE ]
Wow, that has all the negatives, and almost none of the positives.

[shortline99]

People who have mentioned a desire to vote VR but aren't doing it:

Boiler
Mets
IY
Kyro

[KyrosMother]

Hmmm...let the body-hopping begin.

This actually makes me suspect GT more. Why come out now? If he is good, why not wait a little and see what happens. He only has 5 votes and people are still moving around.

If he is evil, he is more likely to be believed because he claimed early. This gets him one night to body-hop and even potentially opens up Amp, if the doctor decides to believe GT.

I'm not changing yet, but there is a real good chance I may.

[fnord_too]

edit, GT posted his plan when I was composing. I have to think about it but at first glance I really don't like it. I think it is exploitable by the demons whether he is a demon or not. If he is telling the truth, it may work but I really with he would have posted this as a hypothetical because if he is telling the truth he has hosed the village since now we lose amp or another power role unless the angel rand()s and we luck box.