Star Trek Game Thread - Page 5

LuckayLuck · #41 09-03-2007, 01:57 PM

also, this is a lot of lol

[ QUOTE ]
Kes(F) - Seer. Gets a peek on Night 0. Dies no matter what after end of Day 9

[/ QUOTE ]

over/under on the last ability being relevant?

10:1 odds against??

LuckayLuck · #42 09-03-2007, 01:58 PM

[ QUOTE ]
WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT
ALTERNATE STRATEGY INCOMING. DO NOT COME OUT, DOCTOR

1. The Doctor does NOT roleclaim.
2. If Troi/Kes/Riker/Kirk are getting bandwagoned, (OR, THE DOCTOR HIMSELF), THEY CLAIM DOCTOR.
3. The Doctor does not say anything about this.

Ingenious!

[/ QUOTE ]

actually, upon some re-evaluation, every power village role should claim doctor if they are being threatened with a lynch

clowntable · #43 09-03-2007, 01:59 PM

[ QUOTE ]
Howdy all!

It's nice being back in a game after a two month dry spell...

A couple thoughts... Night is MIDNIGHT (EDT)??? Ouch... That's going to cut down on east coast snipers.

The Borg queen living to the later game stages (Day 7+) can be devastating. That is when we have cleared villagers and an assimilation will wreck havoc...

Oh and vote clowntable... His rand() has been smashed to bits and he's stuck ALWAYS being a wolf in all long games.

[/ QUOTE ]
Such a horrible first post.
mark

LuckayLuck · #44 09-03-2007, 01:59 PM

Dustin, Mark, and Nez:

I am a plain, regular Starfleet dude with no extra powers or abilities at all.

Discuss.

clowntable · #45 09-03-2007, 02:01 PM

[ QUOTE ]
Holographic doctor immediately roleclaims:

Pros
<ul type="square">[*]Troi doesn't waste a view on the doc[*]Kes doesn't waste a view on the doc[*]Riker doesn't waste a sleep on the doc[*]Kirk doesn't waste a sleep on the doc[*]Spock doesn't commit seppuku on the doc[*]Picard doesn't waste a hunt on the doc[*]McCoy doesn't waste an angel protect on the doc[*]Villagers don't waste time discussing lynching the doc[*]Villagers can take the doc's word on face value[/list]

Cons
<ul type="square">[*]Khan doesn't waste a view on the doc[/list]

Conclusion:

Would the holographic doctor please come out, please come out, please come out?

[/ QUOTE ]
One more con:
Supersecret role vs claiming (I'm 90% sure it does't exist though)

p.s.: ZOMG OT vs the czechs ZOMG

DustinG · #46 09-03-2007, 02:02 PM

[ QUOTE ]
Dustin, Mark, and Nez:

I am a plain, regular Starfleet dude with no extra powers or abilities at all.

Discuss.

[/ QUOTE ]

there are 3 of those?

doesnt bode well for you

of course who knows whether or not to believe you

whats interesting is lets say you get wagoned and dont claim anything- then you're both more likely to be a wolf and more likely not to be a wolf

Mark_K · #47 09-03-2007, 02:02 PM

[ QUOTE ]
WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT
ALTERNATE STRATEGY INCOMING. DO NOT COME OUT, DOCTOR

1. The Doctor does NOT roleclaim.
2. If Troi/Kes/Riker/Kirk/Romulan #1,/Romulan #2/Borg Queen... are getting bandwagoned, (OR, THE DOCTOR HIMSELF), THEY CLAIM DOCTOR.
3. The Doctor does not say anything about this.

Ingenious!

[/ QUOTE ]

Brilliant!

LuckayLuck · #48 09-03-2007, 02:03 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT
ALTERNATE STRATEGY INCOMING. DO NOT COME OUT, DOCTOR

1. The Doctor does NOT roleclaim.
2. If Troi/Kes/Riker/Kirk/Romulan #1,/Romulan #2/Borg Queen... are getting bandwagoned, (OR, THE DOCTOR HIMSELF), THEY CLAIM DOCTOR.
3. The Doctor does not say anything about this.

Ingenious!

[/ QUOTE ]

Brilliant!

[/ QUOTE ]

...

...

[vote Mark K]

he's almost certainly a romulan here

RoundTower · #49 09-03-2007, 02:04 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT
ALTERNATE STRATEGY INCOMING. DO NOT COME OUT, DOCTOR

1. The Doctor does NOT roleclaim.
2. If Troi/Kes/Riker/Kirk are getting bandwagoned, (OR, THE DOCTOR HIMSELF), THEY CLAIM DOCTOR.
3. The Doctor does not say anything about this.

Ingenious!

[/ QUOTE ]

actually, upon some re-evaluation, every power village role should claim doctor if they are being threatened with a lynch

[/ QUOTE ]
This suggests vanilla villagers should also sometimes claim doctor when threatened with a lynch? Otherwise, the wolves know the lynch candidate is almost certainly an eatable power villager. Also evils will at least sometimes claim doctor, so how many doctors will we have by the end of the game?

LuckayLuck · #50 09-03-2007, 02:06 PM

The reason why all power villagers claiming doctor is a good idea:

1. Nearly all power villagers have some way to prove that they are a power villager.

2. If the Romulans decide to kill a claimed doctor, they could hit Data or the real doctor, which would be very bad for them.

3. If the Romulans decide to claim doctor, they will eventually be outed.