MAFIA 2 Game Thread

[LuckayLuck]

btw, if the order to vigilante someone is given out, then if that someone is a special role, he should assume he's going to be shot at night and should therefore claim during the day

[LuckayLuck]

most of the time, we're going to be voting to vigilante'ing the #2 on the lynch. However, if #1 turns out to be a wolf, vigilante should reconsider, since he gets extra information

[LuckayLuck]

additional bonus:

we'll know who the mafia killed, and who the vigilante killed

[soah]

personally I think it would be better if the vigilante just shoots whoever I think should die

[soah]

I'm afraid this is turning out like the last game I played where all the wolfs were stuck on airplanes in puerto rico and stuff and so there was nothing to do the whole day

[LuckayLuck]

[ QUOTE ]
personally I think it would be better if the vigilante just shoots whoever I think should die

[/ QUOTE ]

don't you see the benefit of having the village VOTE for who the vigilante to shoot?

not only does it provide a more informed decision, but also:

1. we know who the vigilante shoots and who the wolves kill
2. if the target is a seer or doctor, they can claim

[soah]

the village has wolfs in it

the vigilante has 100% pro-village intentions

so I'd rather have the vigilante trust his own judgement over a village vote

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]

so I'd rather have the vigilante trust his own judgement over a village vote

[/ QUOTE ]
Considering what soah thinks about most people here (and yes, I think this too about a lot of people's finding wolf skillz), I don't think this is something soah-villager would say. Yeah, it makes sense. Yeah, it sounds reasonable.

But what soah said earlier about people trusting his judgement is a lot more soah-like.

[soah]

roflcopter

[lastchance]

Well, it's a theory.

Perfectly fine if it's not true.