situation puzzle #1 $1 and a punch in the face

[TheSickening]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Were there any service rendered?

[/ QUOTE ]
no

[/ QUOTE ]

What about a sale of a product

[ScottHoward]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Were there any service rendered?

[/ QUOTE ]
no

[/ QUOTE ]

What about a sale of a product

[/ QUOTE ]
no

[dmk]

is the $1 at all relevant to the puzzle?
is the amount significant?
is being punched in the face (rather than the arm, etc) significant?

[Sarge85]

Is man #2 pleased after being punched?

Sarge

[TheSickening]

Okay, so #2 is homeless, #1 walks up and gives him a $1 and says, "go buy a [censored] shirt, you filthy bastard" #1 returns to find #2 drinking vodka and punches him in the face for being a tool? getting close?

[ScottHoward]

[ QUOTE ]
is the $1 at all relevant to the puzzle?
is the amount significant?
is being punched in the face (rather than the arm, etc) significant?

[/ QUOTE ]
kinda, but no.
no,it could have been a different amount.
no

[ScottHoward]

[ QUOTE ]
Is man #2 pleased after being punched?

Sarge

[/ QUOTE ]
no

[ScottHoward]

[ QUOTE ]
Okay, so #2 is homeless, #1 walks up and gives him a $1 and says, "go buy a [censored] shirt, you filthy bastard" #1 returns to find #2 drinking vodka and punches him in the face for being a tool? getting close?

[/ QUOTE ]
meh, i wont answer this broad of a question

[TheSickening]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Okay, so #2 is homeless, #1 walks up and gives him a $1 and says, "go buy a [censored] shirt, you filthy bastard" #1 returns to find #2 drinking vodka and punches him in the face for being a tool? getting close?

[/ QUOTE ]
meh, i wont answer this broad of a question

[/ QUOTE ]

so you're saying it's close, I'm a quit while I'm ahead

[sighing]

Were there any actions between giving the dollar and throwing the punch?

Did the man expect to receive the dollar?