**American Idol Finals: The American Songbook

[Jurollo]

First 3 have all been very good in my opinion.

[Miah]

Kelly just dropped half her value on wsex despite the obvious downplaying of her horrendous performance by the judges

[TStoneMBD]

the thing about kellie is that she can have bad performances and her fan base will still carry her deep. i dont think shes going to lose many voters because of that performance. whether she wins or not will largely have to do with how she performs later in the competition. i think these performances are just practice for her because people are voting for HER and not for her talent. her performing bad is going to foreshadow bad performances in the future though because if she cant get the job done now she wont later. at least she knew she butchered the song.

i could be wrong though.

[Hornacek]

I just decided, if my gf and I ever break up, I'm going to marry Kat McPhee.

I have the McPhever. [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

[heater]

[ QUOTE ]
I just decided, if my gf and I ever break up, I'm going to marry Kat McPhee.

I have the McPhever. [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

[/ QUOTE ]

She was amazing.

[Gary Stevenson]

top 3 of the night- katherine, paris and chris
bottom 3 should be- ace, elliot and kellie with ace going home
i think bottom 3 will be- ace, elliot and taylor with elliot going home

[nyc999]

I think Elliot is getting the boot. Ace did enough to buy another week. Everyone else besides Kellie was strong, and there is no way she's going home.

[nyc999]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I just decided, if my gf and I ever break up, I'm going to marry Kat McPhee.

I have the McPhever. [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

[/ QUOTE ]

She was amazing.

[/ QUOTE ]

[FakeKramer]

[ QUOTE ]
top 3 of the night- katherine, paris and chris
bottom 3 should be- ace, elliot and kellie with ace going home
i think bottom 3 will be- ace, elliot and taylor with elliot going home

[/ QUOTE ]I disagree. Kellie dug her own grave by saying "I butchered it" immediately when she was done. I will be very surprised if she is back next week.

[revots33]

"Ahhh butch-ered it!" LMAO.

Not getting the over-the-top praise for Kat's so-so performance. Sorry Simon, PARIS is the one who was in another league vocally tonight.

Taylor was awesome, as usual.