Is Keyshawn Johnson a Hall of Famer?

[capone0]

I don't know if it's that tight for a position like WR which has 60+ starters in a 2 wide set or if a teams base is 3 there can be even more WRs.

I think of the players in the NFL with 8+ more years in the league, the following are probally HOF material.

The only real clear cut HOFer is Marvin Harrison, I think he's a rediculous lock

I personally think TO is a lock but I think a lot will argue he isn't.

I think if Randy Moss cleans his act he'll be a lock to in NE.

I'm not sure what to think about Jimmy Smith, Rod S, Keenan, and Bruce. I think of the 4 Bruce is the best. But then again he was only rediculously good for a couple of seasons.

[BobboFitos]

i always liked jimmy smith

[fingokra]

Guys with 8 or more years experience I think are "virtual locks" right now:

Marvin Harrison, Tory Holt, Randy Moss, Terrell Owens, Isaac Bruce

Guys with 8 or more years experience that need to improve their resumes before making it in:

Derrick Mason, Keenan McCardell, Eric Moulds, Laveranues Coles, Donald Driver, Joe Horn, Darrell Jackson, Keyshon Johnson, Eddie Kennison, Amani Toomer, Rod Smith, Ricky Proehl(lol), Hines Ward (although I think Ward is getting close with considertion of playing in the Steelers Offense)

[Shadowrun]

I dont see how anyone can think TO isnt HOF caliber by the numbers (regardless of his issues)

It sucks that jimmy played in jax (not a lot of media attention), his numbers are more solid then keyshawns so if you think keyshwan is barely out of the HOF jimmy should be in. However, if you think keyshawn isnt even close jimmy shouldnt be in it either.

[Needle77]

Put in Andre Reed and put in Jimmy Smith. Don't put in Keyshawn.

[BellagioPlayer]

Art Monk...

[SuperUberBob]

[ QUOTE ]
Put in Cris Carter and put in Jimmy Smith. Don't put in Keyshawn.

[/ QUOTE ]

IMO Carter is more deserving of a pro football HoF induction than any other retired WR not yet inducted. When he becomes eligible, his induction should be unanimous.

[TheNoodleMan]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Put in Cris Carter and put in Jimmy Smith. Don't put in Keyshawn.

[/ QUOTE ]

IMO Carter is more deserving of a pro football HoF induction than any other retired WR not yet inducted. When he becomes eligible, his induction should be unanimous.

[/ QUOTE ]
No kidding captain obvious.

[MEbenhoe]

[ QUOTE ]

Guys with 8 or more years experience that need to improve their resumes before making it in:

Derrick Mason, Keenan McCardell, Eric Moulds, Laveranues Coles, Donald Driver, Joe Horn, Darrell Jackson, Keyshon Johnson, Eddie Kennison, Amani Toomer, Rod Smith, Ricky Proehl(lol), Hines Ward (although I think Ward is getting close with considertion of playing in the Steelers Offense)

[/ QUOTE ]

there is not a single player on this list that will ever be a HOFer

[BellagioPlayer]

Ward could make it with about 5-6 more Pro Bowl type seasons and a Super Bowl win mixed in.