|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Re: The immigration issue (YouTube Republican debate)
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ] [ QUOTE ] [ QUOTE ] What percentage of this issue is just racism, do you think? (I heard the words "assimilate" and "be a part our culture" a lot from the candidates, which sounds a heck of a lot like code to me.) [/ QUOTE ] I think 90% of the issue is culture, not racism. Have you been to a fast food restaurant or retail store lately? No one working in those places speaks English anymore. As long as the majority of the workforce that people interact with on a daily basis have 0 language skills, people will be pissed of about illegal immigration, regardless of whether those people are illegal immigrants. That and its nice to be able to go to Home Depot without being swarmed by illegal immigrants asking you if you need help. [/ QUOTE ] In return, stuff is cheaper. [/ QUOTE ] Compared to less illegal immigration, a broken legal immigration system and a broken welfare system, yes. Compared to less illegal immmigration, an effective legal immigration/guest worker program and a welfare system that puts people to work instead of feeding them life support, no. [/ QUOTE ] How is limiting immigration ever going to drive prices down? I mean, if you lump in "removing welfare" with your limiting of immigration I'm sure you are going to get a NET decrease in costs, but its in SPITE of your legal immigration system and not because of it. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Re: The immigration issue (YouTube Republican debate)
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ] [ QUOTE ] [ QUOTE ] [ QUOTE ] What percentage of this issue is just racism, do you think? (I heard the words "assimilate" and "be a part our culture" a lot from the candidates, which sounds a heck of a lot like code to me.) [/ QUOTE ] I think 90% of the issue is culture, not racism. Have you been to a fast food restaurant or retail store lately? No one working in those places speaks English anymore. As long as the majority of the workforce that people interact with on a daily basis have 0 language skills, people will be pissed of about illegal immigration, regardless of whether those people are illegal immigrants. That and its nice to be able to go to Home Depot without being swarmed by illegal immigrants asking you if you need help. [/ QUOTE ] In return, stuff is cheaper. [/ QUOTE ] Compared to less illegal immigration, a broken legal immigration system and a broken welfare system, yes. Compared to less illegal immmigration, an effective legal immigration/guest worker program and a welfare system that puts people to work instead of feeding them life support, no. [/ QUOTE ] How is limiting immigration ever going to drive prices down? I mean, if you lump in "removing welfare" with your limiting of immigration I'm sure you are going to get a NET decrease in costs, but its in SPITE of your legal immigration system and not because of it. [/ QUOTE ] Its not in spite of nor because of, its a package of rational policies that would result in whatever the necessary levels of immigration/guest workers are and reduce welfare costs at the same time. the net result is the same or lower prices and lower taxes/smaller deficits |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Re: The immigration issue (YouTube Republican debate)
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ] What percentage of this issue is just racism, do you think? (I heard the words "assimilate" and "be a part our culture" a lot from the candidates, which sounds a heck of a lot like code to me.) [/ QUOTE ] I think 90% of the issue is culture, not racism. Have you been to a fast food restaurant or retail store lately? No one working in those places speaks English anymore. As long as the majority of the workforce that people interact with on a daily basis have 0 language skills, people will be pissed of about illegal immigration, regardless of whether those people are illegal immigrants. That and its nice to be able to go to Home Depot without being swarmed by illegal immigrants asking you if you need help. [/ QUOTE ] this doesnt really make sense imo. if enough ppl felt like this, there would be tons of restaurants and retail stores run by regular americans. also, if u dont like the staff at a place you do actually have a choice to not buy anything from them.. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Re: The immigration issue (YouTube Republican debate)
McCain is a national hero?
Oh wait, I forgot that for some reason people consider bad things happening to you to be heroic. Nevermind, carry on. *goes and heroicly jumps into the Grand Canyon* |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Re: The immigration issue (YouTube Republican debate)
[ QUOTE ]
McCain is a national hero? Oh wait, I forgot that for some reason people consider bad things happening to you to be heroic. Nevermind, carry on. *goes and heroicly jumps into the Grand Canyon* [/ QUOTE ] Yeah, McCain as a National hero is a joke. The guy has always been a complete baffoon. From what I understood, there are a few reasons why Republicans are very anti-immigration. 1) The cost. A welfare state and open immigration cannot coexist. When you get free health care, free schooling of your kids, and other handouts, this gets extremely expensive. Immigrants (at least the illegal ones) rarely make enough money to cover these benefits. 2) Security. If anyone can come into your country, maybe the turrirsts can come in too! 3) Direction of the country. This one particularly worries Republicans. Countries where immigrants come from typically have the attitude that government's role is to provide for its people. When 10 million people come across the border, the next step is to become a citizen. When they become citizens, they can vote. When they can vote, you will have 10 million new Democrats to vote them out. At least these are their concerns, not necessarily all of them are valid. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Re: The immigration issue (YouTube Republican debate)
[ QUOTE ]
McCain is a national hero? Oh wait, I forgot that for some reason people consider bad things happening to you to be heroic. Nevermind, carry on. *goes and heroicly jumps into the Grand Canyon* [/ QUOTE ] forget your coffee before posting this morning? |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Re: The immigration issue (YouTube Republican debate)
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ] McCain is a national hero? Oh wait, I forgot that for some reason people consider bad things happening to you to be heroic. Nevermind, carry on. *goes and heroicly jumps into the Grand Canyon* [/ QUOTE ] forget your coffee before posting this morning? [/ QUOTE ] I thought it was hilarious. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Re: The immigration issue (YouTube Republican debate)
Just to confirm: illegal (excuse me dennis kucinich, undocumented) immigrants pay taxes? Is that a fact, jack?
|
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Re: The immigration issue (YouTube Republican debate)
[ QUOTE ]
Just to confirm: illegal (excuse me dennis kucinich, undocumented) immigrants pay taxes? Is that a fact, jack? [/ QUOTE ] They certainly pay sales taxes when they buy things. Illegal immigrants who are assigned fake SS #s by their employers are also paying payroll taxes and aren't be eligible to collect any of the benefits. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Re: The immigration issue (YouTube Republican debate)
[ QUOTE ]
Just to confirm: illegal (excuse me dennis kucinich, undocumented) immigrants pay taxes? Is that a fact, jack? [/ QUOTE ] Fact. |
|
|