Halloween WW - Costume Party (Game Thread)

[JennFox]

you may or may not need to if we could just spare you one night and lynch fmx; his lynch would explain a lot imo

[antidan444]

[ QUOTE ]
but if we lynch oh, and he is unlynchable and like he says, there will be no lynch at all, then doesnt that constitute as a day with no lynch?

[/ QUOTE ]

I have no idea what would happen in that scenario, and am not even going to pretend I do.

[antidan444]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Our House,

Do you stand by your claim of Headless Horseman?

[/ QUOTE ]
I hope you're kidding.

Headless Horseman is a name I just threw out there. It's completely independent of my lynch dodge power. You think I'm gonna name my real role name??

[/ QUOTE ]

I would think your power matters a lot more than your name.

[fmxda]

[ QUOTE ]
you may or may not need to if we could just spare you one night and lynch fmx; his lynch would explain a lot imo

[/ QUOTE ]
You keep saying it would "explain a lot"

What exactly would it explain? That you guys are anti-village or idiots? Also you make it sound like you expect me to come up village, I am creeped out by that.

[fmxda]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Our House,

Do you stand by your claim of Headless Horseman?

[/ QUOTE ]
I hope you're kidding.

Headless Horseman is a name I just threw out there. It's completely independent of my lynch dodge power. You think I'm gonna name my real role name??

[/ QUOTE ]

I would think your power matters a lot more than your name.

[/ QUOTE ]
Yea I mean the power, I could care less about the name

[fmxda]

*** THIS POST IS DIRECTED AT ANYONE BUT CLOWN OR JENN ***

Then isn't the best course of action to lynch OH, and have me or whoever the consensus 2nd most likely wolf be the backup lynch?

Right there are a bunch of possibilities if we make OH the leading wagon:
1) OH is the HH, lynch transfers onto 2nd most likely wolf (probably me -.-) = <font color="green">consensus wolf suspect lynched</font>
2) OH is the HH, however lynch does not transfer and we have a no lynch = <font color="red">worst outcome, but Nich is proved to be a liar and likely wolf</font>
3) OH is a wolf = <font color="green">we lynch a wolf yay!</font>

(Side note: There is a fourth possibility that I discount which is OH and nichp both being neutrals. I just think it's too unlikely for the game to play out this way if that were the case. Nichp having pushed a Pyramid lynch and OH claiming a village role early is not how neutrals would play. Also there are likely less neutrals than villagers/wolves so conditional probability makes this possibility very low.)

Making OH the leading wagon instead of me means we lynch me anyway some of the time, get a sure wolf in OH another part of the time, or at least expose Nich to be a very wolfy liar in the worst case.

I fail to see how this is worse than taking the line of just blindly lynching me.

[antidan444]

Frankly, lynch FMX or OH, I don't really care which. I would still vote for FMX. Lynching nich here, IMO, would be mega-retarded.

[fmxda]

*** DMK ***
I request mod clarification on what happens if someone immune to lynch ends up with a majority of votes at sundown.

[JennFox]

i have to go to bed pretty soon... i guess i hope the village goes with clowntable and i on this... will be leaving pretty soon.

[Our House]

Nich:

[ QUOTE ]
a) no counterclaim

[/ QUOTE ]
Listen...

I know everyone (some more than others [ahem...waffles]) in the game is anxious to know more about my role. It's not happening. Please don't ask. If I give any more information about how I can be killed, I risk putting my life, and the village's game, in jeopardy. Just accept that I have no outgoing powers...that's all anyone needs to know.