LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring (GAME THREAD)

[sighing]

[ 1 ] aaronk voted for TFG
[ 1 ] amplify
[ 1 ] clowntable voted for wdcbooks
[ 0 ] dmk voted for wdcbooks
[ 0 ] econophile voted for TFG
[ 0 ] fmxda
[ 0 ] GT1T
[ 0 ] herbie voted for clowntable
[ 1 ] Iron_Yuppie voted for VR
[ 0 ] jeremy
[ 0 ] kumubou voted for aaronk
[ 1 ] lastchance
[ 0 ] luckay voted for amplify
[ 0 ] Neil Stevens voted for nez
[ 1 ] nez voted for TFG
[ 0 ] nichp
[ 0 ] soah
[ 0 ] stephen voted for zero
[ 4 ] TFG voted for lastchance
[ 0 ] thebram voted for Iron_Yuppie
[ 0 ] traz
[ 0 ] voj voted for VR
[ 2 ] VR
[ 2 ] wdcbooks voted for zero
[ 2 ] zero
[ 0 ] zurvan voted for TFG

[VoraciousReader]

[ QUOTE ]
VR since I have to pick up a random person, why not taking one who hasn't posted.


[/ QUOTE ]

0 for 2.

Item: Zurvan is a villager in this game.

[VoraciousReader]

Also, I am generally opposed to dividing up seer peeks...but I think with the masonry possibilities in this game, it may not have as big a downside as usual.

If Sam/Frodo do decide to reveal, I think he needs to specify if he's going to be following the "divided" strategy. One seer following it + one not following = bad news.

On balance, I still think it's a mistake, but if you guys decide to do it anyway, I think we can reduce the harm in this game.

Going to nap some more now.

[clowntable]

[ QUOTE ]
Moving on to Clowntable

[/ QUOTE ]
Bad vote.

[lastchance]

I think this is correct. Villager peeks are best used all at once, like a one shot mass confirming all of them, because wolves will need to beat the village to mass confirmeds and win. If a villager is up for lynch, then Sam can come out with it. IMHO, Sam has a lot of play with his villager peeks (knowing that he will always be able to get his peeks off). He can metagame wolves, set traps, etc. Very, very fun role.

That said, I still don't know if it's worth the risk, especially considering seers can leave good hints (blatant ones).

Also, divide up peek plan is solid (though less so with a Godfather). Confirmed villagers are very, very scary for wolves.

[LuckayLuck]

If The One Ring was a bowling pin, then the Fires of Mordor would be a bowling ball. Fine adventurers and fellows, let us throw a strike this day.

[LuckayLuck]

If countif() was sand, we'd be a beach.

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
If The One Ring was a bowling pin, then the Fires of Mordor would be a bowling ball. Fine adventurers and fellows, let us throw a strike this day.

[/ QUOTE ]
LAWL. Masons?

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
traz could very well be a wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]
I see this.

traz

[LuckayLuck]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
If The One Ring was a bowling pin, then the Fires of Mordor would be a bowling ball. Fine adventurers and fellows, let us throw a strike this day.

[/ QUOTE ]
LAWL. Masons?

[/ QUOTE ]
lastchance if somebody tossed you off a roof I would try to catch you.