LOTR: Return of the King (GAME THREAD)

[FortFun]

2+2 has been down for me all morning. My list of wolfyness goes something like jeremy/bram/chuckles/stephan/fmxda/FCBL/me. A few of those can be switched a spot, but I'm pretty happy with it.

[fmxda]

Day 1

<font color="green">[ 5 ] aaronk56 voted for Zurvan</font>
<font color="red">[ 0 ] clowntable voted for Zurvan</font>
[ 0 ] FCBLComish voted for Zurvan
<font color="green">[ 1 ] fmxda voted for Zurvan</font>
<font color="red">[ 4 ] HerbieGRD voted for Zurvan</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Jack Bando voted for Zurvan</font>
[ 0 ] KyrosMother voted for Zurvan
<font color="green">[ 1 ] Mark_K voted for Zurvan</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] VoraciousReader voted for Zurvan</font>

[ 1 ] FortFun voted for aaronk56
[ 0 ] Stephen H voted for aaronk56
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Nez477 voted for aaronk56</font>
<font color="green">[ 1 ] Nicholasp27 voted for aaronk56</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] LuckayLuck voted for aaronk56</font>

<font color="green">[ 0 ] GetThere1Time voted for HerbieGRD</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] RichC. voted for HerbieGRD</font>
<font color="green">[ 9 ] Zurvan voted for HerbieGRD</font>
[ 0 ] Jeremy517 voted for HerbieGRD

<font color="red">[ 0 ] TruFloridaGator voted for fmxda</font>

<font color="red">[ 0 ] wdcbooks voted for FortFun</font>

<font color="green">[ 0 ] dmk voted for Nicholasp27</font>

<font color="green">[ 0 ] chuckleslovakian voted for Mark_K</font>

<font color="green">[ 0 ] Skoob</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] ESKiMO-SiCKNE5S</font>
[ 0 ] Thebram

Day 1 Notes: Not much to analyze here, Nich's claim threw a monkey wrench into the proceedings, and Zurvan got killed in an sad unlucky display of groupthink.


Day 2

<font color="green">[ 0 ] aaronk56 voted for RichC.</font>
<font color="green">[ 6 ] LuckayLuck voted for RichC.</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] DustinG voted for RichC.</font>
[ 0 ] FCBLComish voted for RichC.
<font color="green">[ 2 ] fmxda voted for RichC.</font>

<font color="green">[ 1 ] Jack Bando voted for Mark_K</font>
[ 0 ] Jeremy517 voted for Mark_K
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Nez477 voted for Mark_K</font>

<font color="green">[ 0 ] GetThere1Time voted for LuckayLuck</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] VoraciousReader voted for LuckayLuck</font>
<font color="red">[ 0 ] wdcbooks voted for LuckayLuck</font>
[ 0 ] Thebram voted for LuckayLuck
<font color="green">[ 3 ] Skoob voted for LuckayLuck</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] ESKiMO-SiCKNE5S voted for LuckayLuck</font>


<font color="red">[ 0 ] HerbieGRD voted for Skoob</font>
[ 0 ] chuckleslovakian voted for Skoob
<font color="red">[ 0 ] clowntable voted for Skoob</font>

<font color="green">[ 3 ] Mark_K voted for Jack Bando</font>

<font color="green">[ 0 ] Nicholasp27 voted for dmk</font>


[ 0 ] Stephen H voted for fmxda
<font color="green">[ 1 ] dmk voted for fmxda</font>

<font color="red">[ 0 ] TruFloridaGator</font>
<font color="green">[ 5 ] RichC.</font>
[ 0 ] FortFun

Day 2 Notes:
It must be noted that Herbie, clowntable, chuckles and Vr attempted to change to Rich at the last minute but their votes did not count.


Day 3
<font color="green">[ 4 ] Mark_K voted for DustinG</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Nez477 voted for DustinG</font>
[ 1 ] chuckleslovakian voted for DustinG
<font color="red">[ 1 ] HerbieGRD voted for DustinG</font>
<font color="green">[ 4 ] fmxda voted for DustinG</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Skoob voted for DustinG</font>

<font color="green">[ 0 ] Jack Bando voted for Mark_K</font>
[ 0 ] Jeremy517 voted for Mark_K
[ 1 ] FortFun voted for Mark_K
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Nicholasp27 voted for Mark_K</font>

<font color="green">[ 1 ] RichC. voted for fmxda</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] VoraciousReader voted for fmxda</font>
[ 0 ] Stephen H voted for fmxda
<font color="green">[ 0 ] dmk voted for fmxda</font>

<font color="red">[ 0 ] wdcbooks voted for chuckleslovakian</font>

[ 0 ] Thebram voted for clowntable

<font color="red">[ 1 ] clowntable voted for FortFun</font>

<font color="green">[ 6 ] DustinG voted for HerbieGRD</font>

<font color="green">[ 0 ] ESKiMO-SiCKNE5S voted for FCBLComish</font>

[ 1 ] FCBLComish voted for RichC.

<font color="red">[ 0 ] TruFloridaGator</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] GetThere1Time</font>

Day 3 Notes:
Very little votechanging happened at the end, clearly because no wolves were close to getting wagoned.


Day 4:

<font color="green">[ 0 ] Mark_K voted for chuckleslovakian</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Nez477 voted for chuckleslovakian</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Nicholasp27 voted for chuckleslovakian</font>
<font color="red">[ 1 ] HerbieGRD voted for chuckleslovakian</font>
<font color="red">[ 1 ] clowntable voted for chuckleslovakian</font>
[ 0 ] Thebram voted for chuckleslovakian

<font color="green">[ 0 ] fmxda voted for TruFloridaGator</font>
[ 6 ] chuckleslovakian voted for TruFloridaGator
<font color="green">[ 0 ] dmk voted for TruFloridaGator</font>
[ 0 ] Stephen H voted for TruFloridaGator
<font color="green">[ 1 ] VoraciousReader voted for TruFloridaGator</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] GetThere1Time voted for TruFloridaGator</font>

<font color="red">[ 0 ] wdcbooks voted for VoraciousReader</font>

<font color="green">[ 0 ] ESKiMO-SiCKNE5S voted for clowntable</font>

[ 0 ] Jeremy517 voted for FortFun

[ 1 ] FortFun voted for HerbieGRD

<font color="green">[ 0 ] RichC.</font>
[ 0 ] FCBLComish
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Jack Bando</font>

<font color="red">[ 6 ] TruFloridaGator</font>


Day 5:

[ 2 ] chuckleslovakian voted for clowntable
<font color="green">[ 1 ] fmxda voted for clowntable</font>
[ 0 ] Thebram voted for clowntable
<font color="green">[ 0 ] VoraciousReader voted for clowntable</font>
<font color="green">[ 4 ] Zurvan/RichC voted for clowntable</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Jack Bando voted for clowntable</font>

<font color="red">[ 6 ] clowntable voted for Zurvan/RichC</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Mark_K voted for Zurvan/RichC</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Nez477 voted for Zurvan/RichC</font>
[ 0 ] FCBLComish voted for Zurvan/RichC

<font color="red">[ 1 ] HerbieGRD voted for chuckleslovakian</font>
[ 1 ] Stephen H voted for chuckleslovakian

[ 0 ] Jeremy517 voted for fmxda

<font color="green">[ 0 ] Nicholasp27 voted for HerbieGRD</font>

<font color="red">[ 0 ] wdcbooks voted for Stephen H</font>

[ 0 ] FortFun
<font color="green">[ 0 ] GetThere1Time</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] ESKiMO-SiCKNE5S</font>


Day 7:
[ 0 ] FortFun voted for Mark_K
<font color="red">[ 4 ] HerbieGRD voted for Mark_K</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Jack Bando voted for Mark_K</font>
[ 1 ] Stephen H voted for Mark_K
[ 0 ] Thebram voted for Mark_K
<font color="green">[ 1 ] Nez477 voted for Mark_K</font>

[ 0 ] FCBLComish voted for HerbieGRD
<font color="green">[ 1 ] fmxda voted for HerbieGRD</font>
<font color="green">[ 6 ] Mark_K voted for HerbieGRD</font>
<font color="green">[ 0 ] Nicholasp27 voted for HerbieGRD</font>

[ 0 ] Jeremy517 voted for fmxda

[ 0 ] chuckleslovakian voted for Stephen H

<font color="red">[ 0 ] wdcbooks voted for Nez477 </font>

[Jeremy517]

Stephen pointed out that books cleared Mark and Nez on accident. I don't think he'd do that as wolf, unless it was all an elaborate ruse with books and Stephen is the godfather. Seems unlikely.

FCBL seems villagery to me, and he was probably peeked.

FortFun was probably peeked as well, and would he really be so level 0ish with all his "I'll be AFK tonight" posts?

That leaves chuckles, bram, and fmxda. fmxda has voted for a bunch of wolves, so I would probably put him as least likely in that group of three.

Coincidentally, my three names left are chuckles + two people that chuckles wants to vote off today. If he's wolf, he's likely to name the other wolf as suspicious today.

chuckles

[fmxda]

I think the voting record implicates thebram heavily.

It is interesting Jeremy almost NEVER left his vote on anybody significant. This is excepting day one when he left it on Sauron. I need to reread a few of Jeremy's days before I am sure he is a wolf.

vote thebram

I'm clearing chuckles based on his votes.

From the roles we know, wdcbooks has never voted for a confirmed evil, so I'm willing to award villager points to FortFun and maybe Stephen H.

[Jeremy517]

[ QUOTE ]
It is interesting Jeremy almost NEVER left his vote on anybody significant. This is excepting day one when he left it on Sauron. I need to reread a few of Jeremy's days before I am sure he is a wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]

That is standard for my villager game. Read other games.

[fmxda]

Also I forgot to add the FCBL and FortFun should probably be green in that above table, but I still haven't reread eskimo/skoob (sorry guys!) and I wasn't comfortable putting them as villager.

But I think I'm a bit more sure that they're village, and that neither of them was the godfather.

There are 7 of us and 2 of us are wolves. The odds that either of the two villagers who were peeked (FF and FCBL) is the godfather is pretty low. Especially when I don't think either one is among our two wolfiest suspects (thebram and jeremy).

[fmxda]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
It is interesting Jeremy almost NEVER left his vote on anybody significant. This is excepting day one when he left it on Sauron. I need to reread a few of Jeremy's days before I am sure he is a wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]

That is standard for my villager game. Read other games.

[/ QUOTE ]
It might be standard, but it's nice cover for when you don't have to make an important/incriminating vote too. Explain more why you're not a good lynch?

[FCBLComish]

Based on the voting record, FMXDA seems to be the most clear, along with me and Fort.

Jeremy seems to be the most suspect.

[fmxda]

I need to read thebram's day 5 to see how he ended up on clowntable, whether it was by accident or deliberate (i.e. see when he got on the wagon and how many were on it).

Probably do the same for Jeremy d1 on Herbie.

[Jeremy517]

Actually fmxda is off my list 100%. After aaron came out, fmxda first moved to Herbie, until the protect-Gandalf-wagon went to Zurvan. If he was wolf, he probably would have gone straight to Zurvan.