LOTR: Return of the King (GAME THREAD)

[Nicholasp27]

OVERALL, HIGH-LEVEL SUMMARY:

fact 1: i claimed aragorn d2
fact 2: herbie claimed aragorn a few days later

conclusion: one of herbie/nich is a wolf


fact 3: aaron dying n2 makes me 2x more likely to be aragorn
fact 4: herbie argued yesterday that there is no way he would have killed aaron n2 if he was wolf because he knew skoob was frodo/sam
fact 5: i have proven today that the best course of action for herbie/wolves to take n2 if they knew skoob was frodo/sam would be to kill aaron

conclusion: facts 4&5 cancel each other out, so fact 3 remains that i'm 2x more likely to be aragorn than herbie



if u have questions about any of facts 1-5, i can go into detail about how they are supported, so just ask

[chuckleslovakian]

yeah, can you go into detail about how fact 1 is supported?

[HerbieGRD]

random nitpick - I can prove fact 3 is not correct

[HerbieGRD]

Also - whether "fact 5" is correct or not the correct question is not whether it is correct or not but whether I would have realized that it is correct. I believe my posts from yesterday show pretty conclusively that I wouldn't have but feel free to argue that if you want

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
yeah, can you go into detail about how fact 1 is supported?

[/ QUOTE ]
I've been curious about this one too - fact 1 seems sketchy to me

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
[ 4 ] HerbieGRD voted for Mark_K HATE


[/ QUOTE ]
Also don't hate me Chuck - I love your cat pics!

[Nicholasp27]

[ QUOTE ]
yeah, can you go into detail about how fact 1 is supported?

[/ QUOTE ]

fact 1: post #9994862 was timestamped 04/17/07 at 4:07pm

fact 2: post #9994862 was written by Nicholasp27

fact 3: in post #9994862 is the following quote: [ QUOTE ]
i'm aragorn

[/ QUOTE ]

fact 4: post #9973188 was timestamped 04/16/07 10:53 am

fact 5: post #99973188 was written by sighing

fact 6: sighing is the moderator of LOTR: Return of the King

fact 7: we are playing LOTR: Return of the King

fact 8: in post #99973188 is the following quote: [ QUOTE ]
it is DAY[/b]

fact 9: this was the first day post of the game

fact 10: 04/17/07-04/16/07=1

fact 11: There was a night post on 04/16/07

fact 12: There was a day post on 04/17/07


conclusion: Nicholasp27 claimed Aragorn on the 2nd day of this game

[HerbieGRD]

Nich - I don't buy it

[chuckleslovakian]

[img]/images/graemlins/heart.gif[/img] nich

[Nicholasp27]

ugh; forgot to close quote after fact 8...oops