Halloween WW - Costume Party (Game Thread)

[jgunnip]

VOTE ON DAY 1, 9hrs before lynch.

[ QUOTE ]
[3] antidan voted for vr
[0] boiler
[2] bulletproof eskimo voted for vr
[0] chuck howard voted for dustin
[0] chuckles
[1] clowntable voted for luckay
[0] dazbag
[1] dustin voted for luckay
[1] epicurus voted for our house
[0] fcbl voted for pyramid
[0] fmx voted for antidan
[0] gt1t voted for jgunnip
[1] herbie voted for our house
[0] jennfox
[2] jgunnip voted for our house
[0] km voted for bulletproof eskimo
[2] luckay voted for zurvan
[0] mark voted for herbie
[0] mdorand
[0] mets voted for clowntable
[0] nez voted for our house
[0] nich
<font color="red"> [5] our house voted for epicurus </font>
[1] pyramid voted for jgunnip
[0] roundtower voted for bulletproof eskimo
[0] skillayskill voted for our house
[0] tarheeljks
[3] vr voted for antidan
[0] wdcbooks voted for antidan
[0] zurvan voted for vr

[/ QUOTE ]

5 votes for Oh were Nez, Epi, Herbie, Me, and skillayskill.

3 of the 5 are confirmed non-evils. skillayskill hasn't said much and I think I've been cleared by the pyramid death as well.

I think its unlikely that 5 votes pile on a player on d1 w/o a single wolf vote. Draw your own conclusions. OH is getting my vote today.

[jgunnip]

Jenn and VR would you support an OH vote?

[VoraciousReader]

[ QUOTE ]
are we really going to debate whether chuckles was evil?? regardless of who made him king, chuckles is an obvious wolf. lynch him.


vr, are you trying to prove holes in my argument or prove that your argument has none? bc what you need to be focusing on is the LATTER. kthx.

[/ QUOTE ]

The point that I am making is that being suspicious of me or of chuck based on the fact that we lynched a villager is poor logic. Worse than that, it is lazy, and is why I find it wolfy. There is a whole thread of information to work with, and you are focusing on one decision, which, though a critical one, was made by someone with no more information than you have. The odds of me hitting a villager were huge.

You set me up for it the day before with: "VR better have a good explanation if she kills a villager".

And GT1T called you wolfy for it, and died.

[VoraciousReader]

Yes, I would support an OH vote. If he's a villager, it won't hurt him anyway. OurHouse

[JennFox]

my reads are NOT BASED SOLELY ON YOU LYNCHING A VILLAGER. ITS WHICH VILLAGER AND HOW YOU DECIDED UPON THEM THAT MAKES BOTH OF YOU LOOK WOLFY.

in fact, maybe your evil pumpkin friend put you up to be queen bc he knew youd get off a free lynch at a non-wolf and be able to claim the theory that there are more villagers to be killed than wolves.

thats a convenient argument. luckily the village was around to offer input.

............

[JennFox]

the fact that you had a en entire thread of information on some of these characters, and you of all people are a rereader, why wouldnt you go back and make an informed lynch?

i submit the lynch you made was out of character for any villager to make.

but again, i dont want to lynch your argumentative ass today so stfu and start finding wolves.

the fact that you keep saying that im a wolf bodes badly for you as well, my dear, so knock it off.

[VoraciousReader]

[ QUOTE ]
and your reason for killing him was that he wasnt answering questions..

you see why that doesnt make sense?

[/ QUOTE ]

Of course it does. Classic wolf response: if you don't have a good answer, ignore it and hope they will move on to something else.

[fmxda]

clowntable, chuckles, OH, jennfox, tarheel, in that order ship it

antidan, you shouldnt say who you masoned with, because chances are one of you will be alive to verify this later. (unless possibly the guy u masoned with died, then u may tell us)

[fmxda]

vote clowntable

[JennFox]

you said you lynched him bc he didnt answer your questions.

why did you want to lynch him before you even asked him any questions.

did it really go like this: i had no reason to suspect chuck. im going to ask him questions. uh oh! hes not answering my questions. must be a wolf, even though before not answering questions i had no reason to think this.

??????

before he didnt answer your questions, why would you have lynched him. is not answering you the only reason why you lynched him? bc he seemed mostly absent to me. not ignoring you the way you say..

if you were a wolf that would be a convenient excuse to say you lynched a that particular villager over any of the other more obvious candidates who may have been wolves.