thayers question from the jeter thread - Page 2

Shadowrun · #1 04-12-2007, 01:14 AM

Paul O'Neill got 12 votes.
Scott Brosius was on the list but got no votes.

Im guessing he will get some votes, though no way he should ever get to the HOF.

EDIT: I AM STILL SO PISSED THE HAWK ISNT IN YET
EDIT 2: There should be no debate, he shouldnt get more than 2 percent.

Jack of Arcades · #2 04-12-2007, 01:19 AM

Andre Dawson is essentially the borderline candidate.

Who is Edit 2 referring to? Posada?

Shadowrun · #3 04-12-2007, 01:28 AM

[ QUOTE ]
Andre Dawson is essentially the borderline candidate.

Who is Edit 2 referring to? Posada?

[/ QUOTE ]

yeah

Jack of Arcades · #4 04-12-2007, 01:52 AM

According to BB-Ref, Posada's top comp is... Mike Stanley!? Talk about a small world. Anyway, Stanley was only sort of a catcher so I'm not sure it counts. Posada has been one of the best hitting catchers of the past decade, so make of that what you will.