Peyton Manning, Greatest QB of all time?

[SuperUberBob]

If he wins a Super Bowl, yes.

[DonkeyKongSr]

[ QUOTE ]
if Tom Brady ends up with 4 to 6 rings...where will he rank?

[/ QUOTE ]

Top 50.

[DCopper04]

[ QUOTE ]
kohan = blackjack, no?

[/ QUOTE ]

I was thinking blackjack = manUfan, but I could be wrong. Probably too early to tell without an IP check.

[CharlieDontSurf]

steve young
dan marino
montana
manning

[pokerraja]

[ QUOTE ]
steve young
dan marino
montana
manning

[/ QUOTE ]

add a few more names to the debate:
elway
farve
bradshaw
unitas
nameth

[pokerraja]

i still think Brady has done the most with the least amount of talent around him. manning has had the pleasure of working with all pro receivers and backs compared to brady who has a bunch of nobodies usually.

[Seadood228]

I think if Manning wins one ring, and we extrapolate his stats just a few more years, he will be up there with the greats, but I'm not sure if one SB ring will put him at the top. That being said, he definitely has a shot to get several in his career. If he never gets a ring, he will have quite a dubious distinction.

If Brady were to have a decent career from here on out, I still think he'll be remembered with the greats. There just aren't too many QBs with three rings, and no standout talent around them to lean on. It funny how one loss in a hotly contested game can bring all of the haters.

[ QUOTE ]
steve young
dan marino
montana
manning

[/ QUOTE ]

I'd add Elway, Farve, and possibly Moon to that list, from that era. Seriously I think you can argue to death who the greatest is, IMO they are all equally great, with Joe Montana getting the slight edge over the others..

[Jeff W]

[ QUOTE ]
manning has had the pleasure of working with all pro receivers and backs compared to brady who has a bunch of nobodies usually.

[/ QUOTE ]

Which came first, the chicken or the egg? Funny that the offense was better with Addai/Rhodes this year than it was with perennial pro bowler Edgerrin James last year.

[CharlieDontSurf]

I'll be surprised if Brady doesnt end up with 4 or 5 rings which will put him up there.

[CharlieDontSurf]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
manning has had the pleasure of working with all pro receivers and backs compared to brady who has a bunch of nobodies usually.

[/ QUOTE ]

Which came first, the chicken or the egg? Funny that the offense was better with Addai/Rhodes this year than it was with perennial pro bowler Edgerrin James last year.

[/ QUOTE ]

yes but having Edge, one of the greatest WR of all time, and a fantastic o-line doesn't exactly hurt yr stats