NFL MidSeason Awards

[lastchance]

Tommie Harris > Brian Urlacher.

[NLSoldier]

addai over colston? you gotta be kidding. also bellicheck over peyton? wtf?

i know its no fun to discuss if everyone just agrees, but i think those two are not really arguable.

[tdarko]

"While I'm sure Tomlinson's great day will boost him up some, I'm pretty sure he still won't have been even the best RB this season."

I'm an LJ fan personally, I mean if we are talking about RB's.

[MarkSummers]

belichick does not get coach. john madden actually made a good point during tonight's game when he said that the pats play calling was too tricky. if a team can't stop a run through the middle, why call an end around? a 6-2 start is not a big accomplishment at all for new england, so why does belichick get top coach now. reputation i suspect.

payton should be the best coach through a half season.

[Needle77]

[ QUOTE ]

payton should be the best coach through a half season.

[/ QUOTE ]

Why not Tony Dungy? His team is 8-0.

[Jeff W]

[ QUOTE ]
addai over colston? you gotta be kidding.

[/ QUOTE ]

Colston would be my #2. Addai has the highest run success rate in the NFL at 71% and he's ranked as the 5th most valuable running RB on Football Outsiders(before his very efficient game today) despite playing in a singleback offense. He's also been productive as a receiver(.76 catches/target) and by all accounts is a valuable pass protector.

Colston is close, but I go with Addai.

[ QUOTE ]
also bellicheck over peyton? wtf?

[/ QUOTE ]

Everyone likes the guys that haven't won coach of the year before and the underdog coaches, but I'd take Belichik over any coach in the league. I think he has the best schemes week after week, the best in-game decision making and play calling and he is skilled at developing players and getting the most out of veterans.

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

payton should be the best coach through a half season.

[/ QUOTE ]

Why not Tony Dungy? His team is 8-0.

[/ QUOTE ]

cuz his team was expected to be somewhere around 8-0? Also all of the saints adversity stuff scores peyton lots of points whether deservedly or not.

[MarkSummers]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

payton should be the best coach through a half season.

[/ QUOTE ]

Why not Tony Dungy? His team is 8-0.

[/ QUOTE ]

i would say dungy would be runner up for this. while being 8-0 is great, it's semi expected for the colts. nobody saw the saints at 6-2.

[MacGuyV]

Meh, coach of the year = team the media was the most wrong about in the preseason. Doesn't mean Lovie Smith was a better coach last year than he is this year.

I probably would've said Shannahan last yr; I still don't understand how that team wins so many games.

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
addai over colston? you gotta be kidding.

[/ QUOTE ]

Colston would be my #2. Addai has the highest run success rate in the NFL at 71% and he's ranked as the 5th most valuable running RB on Football Outsiders(before his very efficient game today) despite playing in a singleback offense. He's also been productive as a receiver(.76 catches/target) and by all accounts is a valuable pass protector.

Colston is close, but I go with Addai.

[ QUOTE ]
also bellicheck over peyton? wtf?

[/ QUOTE ]

Everyone likes the guys that haven't won coach of the year before and the underdog coaches, but I'd take Belichik over any coach in the league. I think he has the best schemes week after week, the best in-game decision making and play calling and he is skilled at developing players and getting the most out of veterans.

[/ QUOTE ]

ok agreed sorta. im def not saying peyton is a better coach, im just saying im more impressed with what the saints ahve done this year than what the pats have done considering their players.