Putting Marriage Proposal Ideas into Action...

[ QUOTE ]
Proposing in front of a bunch of people is so lame. It's a private thing, your park idea is best.

[/ QUOTE ]

All ideas could (and would, because I agree with you) be made private.

[oddjob]

[ QUOTE ]
A note about #1 - if you do that, you're stuck watching the movie for the next 2 hours, which will kind of ruin the mood.

Wherever you do it, I'd suggest somewhere where you can screw after.

[/ QUOTE ]

do the park thing, and get a room close by at a nice hotel.

[samjjones]

How about Option #3, with a twist? Take your lady on a date in Washington Sq. Park. Sometime during the date, I (in the visage of a deraged homeless mugger) will mug you and accost your girlfriend. You, being the enormously brave and manly guy you are, will then disarm me and save the damsel in distress. Just then, drop to a knee and give her the ring. Please PM me to negotiate my price.

[SamIAm]

[ QUOTE ]
I will mug you and accost your girlfriend. You will then disarm me and save the damsel in distress. Please PM me to negotiate my price.

[/ QUOTE ]I figured her purse would cover your expenses just fine.
-Sam

[ElaineMonster]

[ QUOTE ]
Idea 1: Movie Coming Attraction Proposal

[/ QUOTE ]

Better idea: Will you marry me trailer.
Rent a silver trailer like this
with paper signs attached to it that read "will you marry me?"

I am only half-kidding. If you're romantic and funny and she's game, this could be brilliant. You could then take the trailer for a weekend road trip to celebrate. It's offbeat, unusual, and if done right, totally heart-stopping, John Cusack in "Say Anything" romantic.

[ QUOTE ]
Idea 2: Planetarium Proposal

[/ QUOTE ]
Or maybe you can get a star named "Will you marry me?"

[ QUOTE ]
Idea 3: Central Park Nighttime Picnic

[/ QUOTE ]
I got nothing.

Bump, because getting less than 200 views in OOT is highway robbery.

[AlphaWice]

Go on a private flight to a vacation spot. While in the air, propose.

[gusmahler]

http://www.nomarriage.com

[kidcolin]

I was on a date and the girl took me out to Blue Man Group. Before the show started the scrolly LED sign posted a marriage proposal for another couple in the audience. Corny as it was, it was absolutely adorable.

[ QUOTE ]
http://www.nomarriage.com

[/ QUOTE ]

Thank you, very helpful.