LOTR: Return of the King (GAME THREAD) - Page 187

Nicholasp27 · #**1861** 04-22-2007, 05:41 PM

i'll even guesstimate exact roles:

sauron: herbie
denethor: mark
witch-king: chuck
oliphant: clown

wdcbooks · #**1862** 04-22-2007, 05:46 PM

Getting rid of me will greatly increase the village's chance to win. There is nothing so powerful as an outed evil, with no powers, who has to make his vote at least an hour before night fall.

I am just surprised I haven't led us to victory yet.

Nicholasp27 · #**1863** 04-22-2007, 05:48 PM

well u've got a tough role, as u can't even influence village like clown/herbie/mark/chuck could since we know u are evil so won't listen to u

but u had some fun

clowntable · #**1864** 04-22-2007, 06:11 PM

I'm pretty sure books can/has and will influence the village [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]
In fact. Yeah books guys let's go. He played very different from what I remember in other games.

Nicholasp27 · #**1865** 04-22-2007, 06:30 PM

dead air dead villager?

j/k

Mark_K · #**1866** 04-22-2007, 06:34 PM

I've been revamping (ripped up my old theories) my village/wolf lists...

I've been looking at voting patterns and posts of various people. Also, I have a tough time believing anyone that voted Clown the last day and also voted Chuck prev is likely a wolf. BTW, Nich I agree with MUCH of your posts today... (OK, everything but me as a wolf)

Here's my current wolf list:

Herbie: GF or Sauron
Clown: Rider
Chuck: GF or Sauron or RB
Stephen: GF or Sauron or RB
WDCBooks: Mouth

BTW, I also think that the above analysis also implicates me but I'm alright with that (unless it's MUST lynch time). I'm big enough to take one for the village. I just ask that we lynch Chuck after Herbie to test my analysis.

FCBLComish · #**1867** 04-22-2007, 06:44 PM

[ QUOTE ]

I've been revamping (ripped up my old theories) my village/wolf lists...

I've been looking at voting patterns and posts of various people. Also, I have a tough time believing anyone that voted Clown the last day and also voted Chuck prev is likely a wolf. BTW, Nich I agree with MUCH of your posts today... (OK, everything but me as a wolf)

Here's my current wolf list:

Herbie: GF or Sauron
Clown: Rider
Chuck: GF or Sauron or RB
Stephen: GF or Sauron or RB
WDCBooks: Mouth

BTW, I also think that the above analysis also implicates me but I'm alright with that (unless it's MUST lynch time). I'm big enough to take one for the village. I just ask that we lynch Chuck after Herbie to test my analysis.

[/ QUOTE ]

Lynch Clown, then Herbie, and see who is eaten in between. We should have it pretty much nailed down by then. After Herbie, if he is Sauron, we can get Books off our backs as well.

FortFun · #**1868** 04-22-2007, 06:55 PM

clown Still at inlaws with crappy dial up only, have not had a chance to read in depth, have read enough to make this vote.

Nicholasp27 · #**1869** 04-22-2007, 06:59 PM

they eat fcbl/fort tonite, other/me tomorrow if we lynch herbie, and other the next night...then vr...then on to unconfirmeds

so we have 4 nights of no info from wolves

Mark_K · #**1870** 04-22-2007, 07:05 PM

BTW, Here's my thoughts for Stephen H being a wolf:

I'm assuming Fmxda is a villager based on his Clown push over Zurvan/RC on day 5 and that Chuck is a wolf

Stephen's votes for the game were:
D1: Aaron
D2: FMXDA
D3: FMXDA
D4: TFG (Pick weaker wolf of Chuck and TFG wolf BW's)
D5: Chuck (Chuck had no BW, Was Zurvan vs Clown) so this can be viewed as a nice "cover" vote.

Stephen also sounded a lot like Clown with his "warming up" to Nez and I. He knew that would give him +villager points.

My guess is: Stephen is the GF, so Herbie has to be Sauron and then Chuck has to be the Witch-King. But this is mostly a guess... (but I think a good one) Who knows? [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]