LOTR: Return of the King (GAME THREAD)

[Nicholasp27]

[ QUOTE ]

It was interesting the way I tried to drive the zurvan wagon all day and got nowhere until it became clear it was zurvan or herbie.

[/ QUOTE ]

interesting observation made by vr d2 about d1

[Nicholasp27]

if i'm aragorn, it was 100% that they got aaron because they knew to roleblock me

if i'm not aragorn, it's just over 50% that they got aragorn (50% protection by herbie + small chance they roleblocked him)


so u have to think herbie is 2x likely to be aragorn over me to vote me instead of herbie

[FCBLComish]

[ QUOTE ]
Nich, why don't you and Herbie make your cases the next three days and we take out Clown Sunday?

[/ QUOTE ]

Jack, Masons for sure!

[Nicholasp27]

does knowing herbie is a wolf help u to better determine clown's role?

[FCBLComish]

[ QUOTE ]
does knowing herbie is a wolf help u to better determine clown's role?

[/ QUOTE ]

Nope, I am assuming fake aragorn is a wolf and we have a few days to discuss. I was interested in your case.

[Jack Bando]

We know what Clown's role is, I'd just like to get rid off all confirmed wolves before we go for unconfirmed wolves.

[Mark_K]

[ QUOTE ]
if i'm aragorn, it was 100% that they got aaron because they knew to roleblock me

if i'm not aragorn, it's just over 50% that they got aragorn (50% protection by herbie + small chance they roleblocked him)


so u have to think herbie is 2x likely to be aragorn over me to vote me instead of herbie

[/ QUOTE ]

This right here is Nich's strongest arguement. It's a good one.

What would Nich have given as an explanation if Aaron had survived that night? The wolves blocked Gandalf and tried to kill me (and I protected myself)? Or they just rolled the dice knowing that if they kill Gandalf, Nich has great cover? Or another angle that I can't think of...

I dunno, but we're going to soon find out.


Nick: Why aren't you actively trying to find wolves in this game? This is so unlike ALL your previous WW villager games. What does your village and wolf list look like?

[Mark_K]

I guess for completeness and symetry:

Herbie - Who do you think the wolves are? What does your current villager-wolf list look like?

What answer do you think Nich gives, if Aaron survived Night2?

[Nez477]

[ QUOTE ]
I guess for completeness and symetry:

Herbie - Who do you think the wolves are? What does your current villager-wolf list look like?

What answer do you think Nich gives, if Aaron survived Night2?

[/ QUOTE ]

Mark,

You are still playing blind man.

Herbie is in no way shape or form more Aragorn than Herbie. I know you think Nich has posted differently, but you need to open up to the thought that he could also be Aragorn.

[Jack Bando]

After scanning through Skoob/Eskimo's posts, which in hindsight are very cover blowing. (YOU AINT LYNCHING ME MANG! NEVER! or WHEN I DIE STUFF WILL MAKE SENSE)

My guesses for their peeks (In order)

DMK-V
Chuckles-V
VR-V
Clown-W

Agree? Disagree?