Star Trek: The Next Generation 3 [GAME THREAD] - Page 166

FCBLComish · #**1651** 04-13-2007, 08:06 PM

[ QUOTE ]
I was under the impression that Books/TFG didn't get a peek because TFG didn't post day 1. So emphasizing that Books was Lwaxanna is just a red herring.

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree. I am sure that TFG got no night action his first day because he was AFK. Soah was specific on this one in thread.

lastchance · #**1652** 04-13-2007, 08:07 PM

More specifically, I think dustin is making a durron type read here. "If you don't think like me, you're a wolf."

I don't think Dustin makes those reads as a villager.

FCBLComish · #**1653** 04-13-2007, 08:08 PM

[ QUOTE ]
More specifically, I think dustin is making a durron type read here. "If you don't think like me, you're a wolf."

I don't think Dustin makes those reads as a villager.

[/ QUOTE ]

Lets get rid of the one we are most sure of, and leave the others until we get more information.

PLEASE VOTE TO LYNCH DUSTIN.

matrix · #**1654** 04-13-2007, 08:10 PM

n1 writeup:

[ QUOTE ]
And the final detail... wdcbooks has replaced TruFloridaGator.

[/ QUOTE ]

no seer peek for Books [img]/images/graemlins/frown.gif[/img]

[censored]

DustinG · #**1655** 04-13-2007, 08:10 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[Books (SEER) d2]I am pretty certain FCBL is village. His role claim (such as it is) doesn't clear him, but I got the feeling he honestly thought it would clear him. Borg would know from the outset that role claims are meaningless.

[/ QUOTE ]

Dustin what do you make of Books claim here - he WOULD have had a peek, which may or may not have gone through. FCBL is the ONLY player he comments on in this fashion.

Did you miss this or just disregard it when you voted FCBL?

you are normally very thorough in your reasons.

The "FCBL knew better about fmxdas wolf game argument" is a weak reason imo to keep voting him.

[/ QUOTE ]

Like Neil said- books didnt get a peek.

It isnt a weak argument at all. They used THE EXACT SAME ARGUMENT against Fmx in MMVII. FCBL modded ASXII where Fmx was very active and game off pretty villagery, and he played in CYOA where Fmx was the same- if he wanted to say on D1 yeah, Fmx is a cop-out, but don't vote me either, then fine, but instead he used reasoning that he just had to know wasn't true.

DustinG · #**1656** 04-13-2007, 08:12 PM

[ QUOTE ]
More specifically, I think dustin is making a durron type read here. "If you don't think like me, you're a wolf."

I don't think Dustin makes those reads as a villager.

[/ QUOTE ]

I've never said that once this game. And I've said I can't read FCBL and proved that in MMII so I'm perfectly justified in going after him for logical type reasons.

soah · #**1657** 04-13-2007, 08:12 PM

[_] dmk votes for DustinG
[1] durron597 votes for matrix
[3] DustinG votes for FCBLComish
[_] Eskimo votes for durron
[2] FCBLComish votes for DustinG
[_] Herbie votes for FCBLComish
[_] Jack Bando votes for
[_] lastchance votes for
[2] matrix votes for DustinG
[2] Neil S votes for matrix
[_] Nez477 votes for
[_] Skoob votes for Neil S
[_] Spook votes for Neil S

[7] Execute dmk (DustinG, FCBLComish, Herbie, lastchance, matrix, Neil, Spook)
[2] Save dmk (Eskimo, Skoob)

matrix · #**1658** 04-13-2007, 08:14 PM

day 1 ASXII fmxda was very INactive as a wolf.

dmk · #**1659** 04-13-2007, 08:14 PM

HOLY [censored] PPL ARE VOTING DUSTIN!!

GOGOGOOGOGOGO!!!

i already said i don't care if i'm executed. i'm not going to put up some huge fight just to get lynched tomorrow instead. i was PRd. if it was the borg, they're going to keep me alive because they know i'm useless. if it was riker, sorry you wasted it on me. obv riker should know that if he PRd me, eskimo = village and if he PRd eskimo, then i'm village. but he can't come out just to save one of us either. that'd be stupid.

lastchance · #**1660** 04-13-2007, 08:14 PM

[ QUOTE ]

It isnt a weak argument at all. They used THE EXACT SAME ARGUMENT against Fmx in MMVII. FCBL modded ASXII where Fmx was very active and game off pretty villagery, and he played in CYOA where Fmx was the same- if he wanted to say on D1 yeah, Fmx is a cop-out, but don't vote me either, then fine, but instead he used reasoning that he just had to know wasn't true.

[/ QUOTE ]
FCBL never actually used this argument in MM7. So, who did? And more importantly, there's no reason for FCBL to know it's false, because he's not paying attention to that kind of stuff when he's a wolf (I don't think), and I know you are.