weekday WW redux

[shortline99]

[ QUOTE ]
oh wow; i just re-read your post about sumzero and it's VERY sketchy and not at all ironclad

now i'm even MORE worried about the bandwagon on sumzero and will NOT vote for sumzero TODAY

i think the wolves are capitalizing on chuckle's mention of sumzero and i don't think we should let them get away with it...chuckle's definitely should have told us sum was a wolf before he died if he had seen him; i really don't believe chuckles saw ANY wolf and the only alive villager (at the time) he had seen was traz, who has now been lynched for that

[/ QUOTE ]

I am sad at everyone.

C'mon, look at SumZero's posts. Please. They literally beat me over the head with the word "wolf."

There's no one else to lynch today. WTF? SumZero is NOT going away. We need to decide on him NOW.

[kyro]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
oh wow; i just re-read your post about sumzero and it's VERY sketchy and not at all ironclad

now i'm even MORE worried about the bandwagon on sumzero and will NOT vote for sumzero TODAY

i think the wolves are capitalizing on chuckle's mention of sumzero and i don't think we should let them get away with it...chuckle's definitely should have told us sum was a wolf before he died if he had seen him; i really don't believe chuckles saw ANY wolf and the only alive villager (at the time) he had seen was traz, who has now been lynched for that

[/ QUOTE ]

I am sad at everyone.

C'mon, look at SumZero's posts. Please. They literally beat me over the head with the word "wolf."

There's no one else to lynch today. WTF? SumZero is NOT going away. We need to decide on him NOW.

[/ QUOTE ]

I find it scary that you just picked up on these "obvious wolf" posts now.

[shortline99]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
oh wow; i just re-read your post about sumzero and it's VERY sketchy and not at all ironclad

now i'm even MORE worried about the bandwagon on sumzero and will NOT vote for sumzero TODAY

i think the wolves are capitalizing on chuckle's mention of sumzero and i don't think we should let them get away with it...chuckle's definitely should have told us sum was a wolf before he died if he had seen him; i really don't believe chuckles saw ANY wolf and the only alive villager (at the time) he had seen was traz, who has now been lynched for that

[/ QUOTE ]

I am sad at everyone.

C'mon, look at SumZero's posts. Please. They literally beat me over the head with the word "wolf."

There's no one else to lynch today. WTF? SumZero is NOT going away. We need to decide on him NOW.

[/ QUOTE ]

I find it scary that you just picked up on these "obvious wolf" posts now.

[/ QUOTE ]

As opposed to last round, when I voted SumZero? And then reiterated my vote?

[.Alex.]

Shortline,

I've posted twice already. I know you missed it since you accused me of not posting earlier, which was after my posts. I don't have much to add beyond that. There's just no point in spending a lot of time thinking about this round.

What I'd actually like to do is have us agree on a villager and have that person pick who we vote for. This will give us the best chance to get a wolf because otherwise, the village has to almost unanimously agree on a person for us to lynch a wolf this round. However, I don't see this plan working in this game because there isn't an obvious villager that we can agree to let him choose our vote.

I'm most likely going to vote sumzero.

[.Alex.]

Nicholas,

If chuckles doesn't have a wolf in his list, then why was he killed??

[kyro]

Here's the way I see it. SZ may or may not be a wolf.

But I don't see how we can let him live to the end of the game. I can definitely see the wolves jumping on this bandwagon, because they knew SZ would be everybody (villager's included) first choice to lynch.

[Nicholasp27]

well, scott had asked chuckles for his opinion and then in the same post said he thought he knew who the seer was but didn't wanna say to hurt him

also, others had said that chuckles/me/someone else were likely wolves or seers

and they may have picked up on what scott saw as well

so lots of reasons

in addition, the fact that his list was WRONG and they knew that we'd go after his top guys that he was pushing (wrongly) if they lynched him and he was the seer (or even if he wasn't, since he came up with a list we may think his list had some merit)

the day we choose to blindly think that a person's list MUST contain a wolf if he was lynched is the day the wolves get even more control with their night kills

[.Alex.]

[ QUOTE ]

in addition, the fact that his list was WRONG and they knew that we'd go after his top guys that he was pushing (wrongly) if they lynched him and he was the seer (or even if he wasn't, since he came up with a list we may think his list had some merit)


[/ QUOTE ]
You know perfectly well that if he was not the seer, we would be giving very little thought to his list. If his list was all villagers, then they would have killed someone else because it was imperative for them to nail the seer. Having 3 villagers as your top suspects is very strong indication that you are not the seer.

I think it's almost certain that there was at least one wolf on chuckles' list.

[.Alex.]

[ QUOTE ]

the day we choose to blindly think that a person's list MUST contain a wolf if he was lynched is the day the wolves get even more control with their night kills

[/ QUOTE ]
Wow, I missed this line. Are kidding me? You were the one advocating in the beginning of the game for the seers to make convoluted suspect lists so that we know who to go for if they die before revealing their info. Now you're saying that we shouldn't be making our decision based on the SEER'S suspect list. You're being horribly inconsistent.

[kyro]

Nick,

I'm going with the wolves here. I'm voting SZ both because I think he actually is a wolf, and because I think it's our best choice at this moment in time.

If he's a wolf, hopefully we'll both make it through the night and we can work off the remainder of our lists.