Star Trek: The Next Generation 3 [GAME THREAD] - Page 157

HerbieGRD · #**1561** 04-13-2007, 06:21 PM

[ QUOTE ]
I've never played with you and have zero read - FWIW I think FCBL sounds genuine - and if I follow that reasoning to it's conclusion I wind up lynching you.

[/ QUOTE ]
Please read LOTR:TTT endgame before deciding to go this route

FCBLComish · #**1562** 04-13-2007, 06:21 PM

[ QUOTE ]
Also - if you can come up with an alternative solution then please by all means do so. The borg wouldn't have known Clown was Bev until after lynch time but Q could have role-revealed Clown already. Once Clown gets lynched the Borg then know that FCBL is the one sending the message and they should kill IY.

[/ QUOTE ]

Herbie, assume for a second that I am Q and I sent the message to the evils. Why would I make it so obvious to put my name into it at all? There were like 13 people whose names could NOT be in the message due to a lack of common letters like "S".

I found my name in there. Someone else found Clown (not clowntable, there was no "T" either.) Yet a third person found IY.

You are trying to put OJ Simpson's glove on your own head and do not realize that it just does not fit.

HerbieGRD · #**1563** 04-13-2007, 06:22 PM

[ QUOTE ]
Why would I make it so obvious to put my name into it at all?

[/ QUOTE ]
How else are they supposed to figure out who you are OMFG

FCBLComish · #**1564** 04-13-2007, 06:22 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I've never played with you and have zero read - FWIW I think FCBL sounds genuine - and if I follow that reasoning to it's conclusion I wind up lynching you.

[/ QUOTE ]
Please read LOTR:TTT endgame before deciding to go this route

[/ QUOTE ]

Actually, Matrix is one of the people (Traz is another) that can read me very easily. He has pegged me as wolf in EVERY game we have played together when I was a wolf.

matrix · #**1565** 04-13-2007, 06:23 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

I don't think it was material to the puzzle - it was probably thrown in just to provide appropriate letters and fill out the Limerick form. Or it could be a further clue that I just don't understand at all.

[/ QUOTE ]

I think it's a BIG clue - and I think that your solution blows because it doesn't incorporate it.

It MUST be a message to kill IY (because IY died) - how else do you explain last night?

How can the borg know Bev was Clown?

[/ QUOTE ]
I agree it was a message to kill IY - note how the three live player names possible from the letters used were
FCBL
Clown
IY

Also note how FCBL was the one to point that out to everyone.

[/ QUOTE ]

IIRC FCBL was fixated on his name - I picked up "IY" and then FCBL later suggested Clown as well. I also remember Neil being annoyed at the time that we two were puzzle solving and not wolf hunting - what does that tell us?

FCBLComish · #**1566** 04-13-2007, 06:23 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Why would I make it so obvious to put my name into it at all?

[/ QUOTE ]
How else are they supposed to figure out who you are OMFG

[/ QUOTE ]

IF I AM Q, WHY WOULD I WANT THEM OR THE VILLAGE TO FIGURE OUT WHO I AM ZOMFG!!!!!

HerbieGRD · #**1567** 04-13-2007, 06:23 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I've never played with you and have zero read - FWIW I think FCBL sounds genuine - and if I follow that reasoning to it's conclusion I wind up lynching you.

[/ QUOTE ]
Please read LOTR:TTT endgame before deciding to go this route

[/ QUOTE ]

Actually, Matrix is one of the people (Traz is another) that can read me very easily. He has pegged me as wolf in EVERY game we have played together when I was a wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]
This argument holds a lot more water when we know Matrix is actually a villager.

durron597 · #**1568** 04-13-2007, 06:24 PM

[ QUOTE ]
Durron I agree my d1 was pretty awful.

FWIW I was coming off the back of being awake for something like 39 hours and had had a bad day - my mind wasn't on the game so I didn't post.

If you are village and think that that is a good enough argument to lynch me then go for it. If enough other people agree with you then I get lynched and you will see how completely wrong you are.

Perhaps some Borg will need to leap onto my wagon to make sure it rolls and I can impart some useful information into this game somehow - so far I have voted to kill fmxda and clowntable - I should have tried to make more noise about luckay maybe cos I was pretty sure he wasn't Borg but meh.

If sucking at the game is reason enough to lynch me .. *shrug*

[/ QUOTE ]

matrix, there is NO ONE LEFT. your posts today suck and your day 1 sucks and i think too many other players are villagers. i can't find any combination of wolves that does not include you.

matrix · #**1569** 04-13-2007, 06:24 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I've never played with you and have zero read - FWIW I think FCBL sounds genuine - and if I follow that reasoning to it's conclusion I wind up lynching you.

[/ QUOTE ]
Please read LOTR:TTT endgame before deciding to go this route

[/ QUOTE ]

I'll read it tonight - I doubt I'll vote you OR fcbl tonight anyway - I'd rather spend the next hour or so reading this thread and wolf hunting.

HerbieGRD · #**1570** 04-13-2007, 06:25 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Why would I make it so obvious to put my name into it at all?

[/ QUOTE ]
How else are they supposed to figure out who you are OMFG

[/ QUOTE ]

IF I AM Q, WHY WOULD I WANT THEM OR THE VILLAGE TO FIGURE OUT WHO I AM ZOMFG!!!!!

[/ QUOTE ]
So they don't nightkill you