Halloween WW - Costume Party (Game Thread)

[Epicurus]

so, if the person you wanted to get lynched was lynched, you got an extra lynch?

and you exercised this power by campaigning to get me lynched, and nominating me as your extra lynch?

im all but speechless.

[clowntable]

I'm kinda stunned everyone ignored my comment about boiler btw

[Mark_K]

[ QUOTE ]

youre "thoughts" sum up to 0. basically your thoughts were that dan is either a wolf or not a wolf, luckay was probably a pumpkin victim, and you didnt know what to think of herbie. monk was suggesting he was a sk/vig, so his silence makes sense? why does it make sense?
i didnt see epicrus claim, so i was doing what i felt was best.
you seem awfully sure epicrus isnt a wolf. odd.

[/ QUOTE ]

Not true, you word twisting howler.

I thought I pointed out several useful (and maybe obvious) things...

1. There exists a Good/neutral Flying Pumpkin. (BTW, this was before I even realised the existance of two pumpkins)
2. AntiDan could be evil and still be silenced (FWIW, I lean village on Dan)
3. I don't have a big epiphany on the Herbie kill.
4. That Monk could be silenced by a villager because he hinted that he was bad for the village.

I think all of these are good points and are the conclusions that I personally got from the night actions.

[VoraciousReader]

[ QUOTE ]
This is KM's son and I think you're all stupid.

[/ QUOTE ]

We should totally fix KM's son up with jennfox. Soulmates.

[VoraciousReader]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Well, since nich doesn't appear to be here:

Chuck:

If we kill OH and he is evil, who will you want to vote?

If we kill OH and he is a villager, who will you want to vote.

I'm all for clearing up day 1 wagons, but when the lynch is 5-5-4 in a 30 person game I think the evils would probably laugh their heads off at the idea we learn anything from wagon theory.

I'm open to the possibility I'm wrong about this. What would we learn? (Open question, anyone else may answer too.)

[/ QUOTE ]

[/ QUOTE ]

[VoraciousReader]

So since nobody has an answer on what we learn from clearing up the wagons, should I assume that is a red herring and just kill nicholasp27?

[VoraciousReader]

Perfect. Everyone is completely speechless at 17 minutes until the kill. If someone doesn't talk to me right now, I'll rand() it. So help me I am 100% serious.

[Mark_K]

[ QUOTE ]
So since nobody has an answer on what we learn from clearing up the wagons, should I assume that is a red herring and just kill nicholasp27?

[/ QUOTE ]

You know my thoughts.

[clowntable]

[ QUOTE ]
So since nobody has an answer on what we learn from clearing up the wagons, should I assume that is a red herring and just kill nicholasp27?

[/ QUOTE ]
I'm too lazy to look it up now. Sure we'll learn somrthing but I'd prefer if you just told us who YOU think is wolfy and why (you gave a list of who you concider, that's all i remember) you'd want to kill them and go with that.
I wouldn't trust a wolf and neutral filled crowd too much.

[Epicurus]

dont kill nichp. apparently hes always utr early on but ive been told has a good late game. dont start thinking chuck is so obvious there must be a sting in the tail. kill chuck. if you're wrong, you're wrong with half the village.