LOTR: Return of the King (GAME THREAD)

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]
Zurvan,

you go from [ QUOTE ]
The first line is fine, if you can show what he did that was wolfy.

[/ QUOTE ]

to [ QUOTE ]
There's plenty for you to evaluate my role based on my posts. If you're going to lynch me, do it based on what I've said.

[/ QUOTE ]


[/ QUOTE ]

I don't really see your point? At least you can show a reason you thought he was wolfy beyong him not posting much. That's good.

It doesn't mean you should lynch me, when we a) have better suspects, and b) I'm giving you plenty of information to decide on my role. Far more than Rich gave you.

[Nez477]

[ QUOTE ]
Ok, I had a quick read before I reallr, really had to be AFK. I am going to unvote and hope I can catch a signal or dial up later tonight before night falls. My vote would like to be chuckles/nich/herbie in that order.

[/ QUOTE ]

I think we can safely say FortFun is not Eowyn.

And is also making no sense.

Yep, we can assume these two things.

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I obviously can't defend Rich's actions. He was useless, and not interested.

I'm going to be bloody irate if I get lynched twice in the same game for no good reason. I posted more in the first hour today than Rich did all game. There's plenty for you to evaluate my role based on my posts. If you're going to lynch me, do it based on what I've said.

[/ QUOTE ]

Why? RichC's post is also part of your record. However, before you get lynched, we have some other business to take care of...

Village vote NICH!!!!

[/ QUOTE ]

Mark

You should start thinking about the game. There's more than 2 people you can vote for today, and many of them make a ton more sense than me, and all of them but Herbie make more sense than Nich.

[Stephen H]

Alright, even in the multi-way mustlynch rounds, I'm okay with there being 2 doctors. With some luck we're getting a free wolf out of this situation.

For today I'd love to see Chuckles/clown wagons.

[fmxda]

stop voting Herbie or Nich. It is just plain wrong.

I would rather rand() between the remaining players than coinflip between Aragorn and a random wolf.

And I'd like to think our lynch will be better than a rand of the remaining players =P

[fmxda]

vote clowntable

[Mark_K]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
BTW, And as Zurvan the smart-wolf, he is doing what he has to do to protect the best interests of the wolves.

Try to push the village off a Nich lynch and sow doubt.

Village, remember there are 12 villagers left, 4 hidden wolves, Books, and Gollum.

Eowyn can still nail the witchking...

We have a %25 chance of Nich being Sauron. This will give us Books. The wolves would be down to 3...

We have a %25 chance Nich is the WitchKing. This would help Frodo/Aragorn/Village in a HUGE way.

%25 chance he's the godfather... A great wolf to kill anytime.

For the record, I'm guessing Zurvan is the Rider. Since that wolf is the most "disposable"

[/ QUOTE ]

Mark,

You assuming that Nich is a wolf and Zurvan is a wolf is baffling the hell out of me.

[/ QUOTE ]

No problem, lets talk through it.

I think one big disconnect between us is the fact that you REALLY believe Herbie is a wolf and I think he is a villager. Is your Herbie "read" THAT strong, that it is able to explain the way Nich is acting in this game?

Maybe we need to review your Herbie is a wolf evidence. I'll do my best to keep an open mind.

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]
Is your Herbie "read" THAT strong, that it is able to explain the way Nich is acting in this game?

[/ QUOTE ]

Is your nich read that strong that it explains the way herbie is acting this game? Enough to take a 50% shot at doing the wolves a huge favour?

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
BEING UTR IS NOT, IN ITSELF, WOLFY

[/ QUOTE ]
How about nightposting before the game starts?

What about pushing Herbie day one who has now made a believable Aragorn claim?

What about slyly saying he could vote for nich, the less believable Aragorn claim, without actually voting him?

What about roleclaiming "hobbit" without any real pressure?

What about randomly voting me as a unrelated addon to a terrible post?

The above is essentially a summary of all the posts he has made in this thread, all 5 of them.

[/ QUOTE ]

WHAT IS BELIEVEABLE ABOUT HERBIE GETTING BLOCKED LAST NIGHT????????

I don't get it at all.

[/ QUOTE ]

VR made a pretty good point on how Herbie gets blocked last night. Also, the wolves have Sauron's names of non-ringbearers - we have no idea what names they know not to bother with for frodo, and if nich is a wolf, then they're killing one person on the list and blocking another.

If I got blocked as aragon or frodo i'd come out the next day, too - no way I wait as I know I'm on the short list to die.

[Mark_K]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Is your Herbie "read" THAT strong, that it is able to explain the way Nich is acting in this game?

[/ QUOTE ]

Is your nich read that strong that it explains the way herbie is acting this game? Enough to take a 50% shot at doing the wolves a huge favour?

[/ QUOTE ]

YES.