Halloween WW - Costume Party (Game Thread)

[VoraciousReader]

I think it's very likely KM is evil. However, she is being very productive and mostly thoughtful, and I don't feel comfortable executing her when there are so many better candidates.

[Epicurus]

i think GT1T has an above average chance of being a villager. i agree that eskimo is far from certain evil but probably still a liability to the village. i dont like a dan lynch on the back of a day of enforced silence. wdcbooks i am back and forth on - on the one hand i believe his attacks on me to be poorly founded. on the other i dont think both he and chuck can be evil, and to my mind chuck is the better lynch for the reasons you state.

[Our House]

[ QUOTE ]
-our house i think is village but misguided in thinking epi is evil

[/ QUOTE ]
Misguided? Meh.

He claims doctor when a wagon starts rolling on him 10 minutes before night. Then today, everyone asks who he protected. He says himself. Then, we call him on it and he claims that protecting himself is "the standard play" in that spot. Then, I tell him how convenient it is and he completely reverses the story (even though he just said it was standard to protect himself!! [img]/images/graemlins/confused.gif[/img]) to say that he protected someone else. Then he won't mention the player's name.

Is that the correct way for a doctor to play?

Epi being village is not obvious.

[wdcbooks]

I don't like the Chuck Norris choice very much and I certainly don't like me. I wasn't inclined to grant Scott his wish for an extra lynch, but I tended to believe his claim to have some kind of extra lynch power.

I obviously hate lynching me, but whatever. I am not exactly a fancy player and I haven't been getting votes recently until quite late in the game. Given my powers I couldn't see how I was going to hit my vote threshhold without begging. I think I am best dropping it for now in hopes that I can be the second wagon to an outed wolf or something.

I think I made a strong case for Epi that was built on some very good logic. I especially think that VR should know that someone who claims to be a doctor who could protect himself was bound to get his role claim shredded. Even worse when Epi realized that he backed off.

[GetThere1Time]

KM is kind of on my watch list. I've havent been reading the thread in close detail but I found it odd she called me a villager when i'd done [censored] all.

If AntiDan is in fact evil, he's a powerful one imo since the silence would only likely buy him another day or so.

[Epicurus]

OH,
I think that the way you describe those events gives a pretty innacurate impression. i have explained my reasons in detail. to repeat the most salient of them - I was under no pressure whatsoever with the story i had told and people were queuing up to say they believed it. if i was lying, why would i alter my story and risk losing that trust?

[VoraciousReader]

Yeah, we're cool books. What is your concern about Norris?

[wdcbooks]

[ QUOTE ]
Yeah, we're cool books. What is your concern about Norris?

[/ QUOTE ]

That I have never noticed Scott to fake role claim beyond his idiotic "seer not seer" stuff. That is about as far as he usually goes and usually isn't interested in sustaining a fiction. It is also that he pushed to kill Epi and I firmly believe Epi is evil, so it would make no sense for Scott to be evil as well.

[SkillaySkill]

vote books

youre all probably evil

[Our House]

[ QUOTE ]
I'm adding JennFox to my wolf list. That last post struck an off chord with me, especially this bit:

[ QUOTE ]

im surprised no one has mentioned the fact that if vr lynches a villager tonight, it will be her ass tomorrow, so choose wisely. why are we all dancing around vr right now? so shes in control. but ONLY for 1 day. tomorrow she is fair game just like the rest of us, so there should be as much pressure on her as there is on us today.


[/ QUOTE ]

[/ QUOTE ]
GT,

Completely agree. The bolded part actually caused me to go "ewwwww" out loud.