LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring (GAME THREAD)

[Neil S]

I'll try to read Luckay today in case it's Voj v Luckay.

[Nicholasp27]

[ QUOTE ]
Seriously, you think they role-blocked traz, but you also think he's wrong? WTF, pick one. They don't role-block him if they don't think he's seer.

[ QUOTE ]

go back a few long games, where i [censored] up about 27 times because i hadn't read the rules thoroughly

[/ QUOTE ]

Maybe you should have learned your lesson, then

[/ QUOTE ]

?

i think he was wrong on tfg/fmx/bram/aaron (first 3 are proven so far)...

i think he saw books n0 villager and then was blocked...weren't there 3 blocks n1 anyway?

[Nicholasp27]

[ QUOTE ]
The Witch-King can't block Frodo AND Aragorn you know. At least, as far as I know. So you can't keep using him as the reason they don't kill either claimed role, Nich.

[/ QUOTE ]

?
they don't care about killing me or aragorn...they wanna kill sam...how many times do i have to post that?

if they kill me, then sam starts getting peeks and they can't block him because they don't know who he is

they'd rather search for sam while i'm roleblocked

[Nicholasp27]

[ QUOTE ]
Because remember: Aragorn can protect Sam 100% right now, so if they're Sam hunting....

[/ QUOTE ]

sam can't come out because i'm already out

and aragorn can't protect sam when he doesn't know who sam is

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Do you really think Sam doesn't out Nich as a fraud by this point if Nich is evil?

[/ QUOTE ]
I don't think Sam comes out until he has at least one immediately actionable peek from Frodo for us. So maybe not.

[/ QUOTE ]
Killing Nich *IS* one immediately actionable peek if he's not really Frodo.

[GetThere1Time]

GetThere1Time is no more. I am GetThereTheWhite

[Neil S]

Nich, I didn't say Sam would come out if you're Frodo. What I am saying is that if Aragorn decides he knows who Sam is, then he can protect Sam perfectly right now.

That's why Sam, not you, should have come out in the first place.

And Stephen, good point on Sam.

[Nicholasp27]

well i had heat on me and i didn't know there were roleblockers so i came out

this is the final time i'm apologizing for the error

[Neil S]

Aww, no, I wasn't trying to rub your nose in that. I just mean, if you really think the evil guys are Sam-hunting right now, then their fear ought to be that Aragorn is protecting *him*, not you.

[GetThere1Time]

Evils wont try to kill nich so long as they can role block him.