Halloween WW - Costume Party (Game Thread)

[FCBLComish]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I said VR was a villager. I was right.

[/ QUOTE ]

oh yea?

[/ QUOTE ]

I think it is already a proven fact.

[metsandfinsfan]

[ QUOTE ]
I still see no reason to clog the post with noise.

I said VR was a villager. I was right.

I say KM is not evil.

I say Pyramid is a wofl, waffle, wolf.


I stand by my day one statements.

VR, do not kill KM.

[/ QUOTE ]

you dont have to clutter the thread the way me eskimo dan clown et al have, but giving us a little insight into your thought process would be superdeeduper.

i led the lynch of you in slow game 1 or 2 when you were a wolf, and i was correct that you had to be lynched because of your utrness. at least here you are posting once per day, but adding a tiny bit of substance to the posts will make me smile

[jgunnip]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I said VR was a villager. I was right.

[/ QUOTE ]

oh yea?

[/ QUOTE ]

I think it is already a proven fact.

[/ QUOTE ]

I think not.

[metsandfinsfan]

it's not a proven fact. vr could have been pumpkined. a neutral could have done this to her. she could be an evil with the power to be queen for a day. who knows

i believe she is good. but fcbl saying it is a fact is quite a stretch

[clowntable]

[ QUOTE ]
it's not a proven fact. vr could have been pumpkined. a neutral could have done this to her. she could be an evil with the power to be queen for a day. who knows

i believe she is good. but fcbl saying it is a fact is quite a stretch

[/ QUOTE ]
That's what I mean. 100% agreed

[KyrosMother]

[ QUOTE ]
she has always wanted me dead since xmen

[/ QUOTE ]

Only on Day 1 - and Eskimo now holds that honor. After Day 1....I actually put thought into it. [img]/images/graemlins/heart.gif[/img]

[jgunnip]

[ QUOTE ]
it's not a proven fact. vr could have been pumpkined. a neutral could have done this to her. she could be an evil with the power to be queen for a day. who knows

i believe she is good. but fcbl saying it is a fact is quite a stretch

[/ QUOTE ]

I believe she is good too. But she just as easily could have been pumpkined and killed last night no? Being queen doesn't absolutely exonerate her of being evil. In MM2 I think one of the mafia members was king for a day.

[metsandfinsfan]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
it's not a proven fact. vr could have been pumpkined. a neutral could have done this to her. she could be an evil with the power to be queen for a day. who knows

i believe she is good. but fcbl saying it is a fact is quite a stretch

[/ QUOTE ]

I believe she is good too. But she just as easily could have been pumpkined and killed last night no? Being queen doesn't absolutely exonerate her of being evil. In MM2 I think one of the mafia members was king for a day.

[/ QUOTE ]

thanks for reiterating what i just said, very helpful

[jgunnip]

I'm just saying that people seem to be ignoring the fact that getting queen for a day could just have easily been a pumpkin death as well. Anyway, we shouldn't be debating this today. We need to figure out good lynches.

[VoraciousReader]

I'd like to point one thing out.

If you think I was pumpkined, how many pumpkins do you think the evils have?

Let's assume for the sake of argument that the evils don't have more than 1 pumpkin. It's unlikely that an Evil Pumpkin pumpkined luckayluck, which means it's dramatically more likely that I was pumpkined by the evil one, which would make me very likely a good player or at worst a neutral.

It is also possible that either luckay (very likely) or me (less likely) was pumpkined night zero and the effects didn't appear until last night. But I do think that the suggestion I was pumpkined pretty strongly points to me being, logically, a villager.

No?

It's of course possible that I have a power. But saying I was pumpkined and am evil seems like the least likely case to me.