LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring (GAME THREAD)

[LuckayLuck]

nich:

a) maybe, but wolves are SEER HTUNING
b) maybe
c) there's no way we lynch our doctor if traz doesn't come up gandalf


nich
I agree 100% with you if traz does NOT come up gandalf that we give aaron a pass (even until one turn before must lynch!) but traz came up gandalf!

work with me here
<u>Who was Traz's N1 peek?</u> We can assume his N2 peek was blocked and his N0 peek was books

[Nicholasp27]

why wasn't his n1 peek blocked after he defended books as such on d1?

[soah]

vote luckay

[Stephen H]

If aaron is doctor, the wolves kill nich whenever they feel like it as long as they have a roleblocker. They don't want to until Sam is dead because right now they can block the seer peeks; if unknown Sam becomes seer then they can't. I can see the night kills working like they did so far - remember, if they kill sam, they follow up with killing nich and then they never have to kill aaron because he's POWERLESS.
If aaron isn't the doctor, then the same strategy still applies. So the night kills make sense whether or not aaron is wolf.

SO DON'T KILL AARON TODAY. Please? For me?

Just kill luckay and let's get it over with. He's wolfy as hell this game.

[LuckayLuck]

[ QUOTE ]
why wasn't his n1 peek blocked after he defended books as such on d1?

[/ QUOTE ]
actually, he defended a lot of people d1, nich
it's only looking back since all these people are dead that we can possibly see it's a books peek. And, blocked n1? Okay, I guess I can buy that

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]
i revealed him as vanillager because he had some heat and i had some heat...figured i'd come out and clear both of the seers, get doc protection and hopefully they'd buy that he was villager

i didn't see that there was a roleblocker, and i apologized for this

[/ QUOTE ]

1. Neither of you was in any danger of getting lynched
2. WTF? You're a rules whore

This is why I think you might be evil, btw.



nez

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
nich:

a) maybe, but wolves are SEER HTUNING
b) maybe
c) there's no way we lynch our doctor if traz doesn't come up gandalf


nich
I agree 100% with you if traz does NOT come up gandalf that we give aaron a pass (even until one turn before must lynch!) but traz came up gandalf!

work with me here
<u>Who was Traz's N1 peek?</u> We can assume his N2 peek was blocked and his N0 peek was books

[/ QUOTE ]

Who knows? Evils got to pick 3 names to block and may very well have blocked traz. Entirely possible he didn't get a N1 peek. I'd find it more likely he got a N2 peek, not N1.

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
i revealed him as vanillager because he had some heat and i had some heat...figured i'd come out and clear both of the seers, get doc protection and hopefully they'd buy that he was villager

i didn't see that there was a roleblocker, and i apologized for this

[/ QUOTE ]

1. Neither of you was in any danger of getting lynched
2. WTF? You're a rules whore

This is why I think you might be evil, btw.



nez

[/ QUOTE ]

Do you really think Sam doesn't out Nich as a fraud by this point if Nich is evil?

[LuckayLuck]

okay, fine.
unvote
you're still wolfy, Stephen.

[Nicholasp27]

i'm not a rules whore

go back a few long games, where i [censored] up about 27 times because i hadn't read the rules thoroughly