Halloween WW - Costume Party (Game Thread)

[RoundTower]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Monk was advertising he was some type of serial killer/vig so his silence makes sense.

[/ QUOTE ]
Huh?

I thought vig = good and SK = evil. His silence only makes sense is he's SK. If he was vig, waffles would KILL him, not silence him.

[/ QUOTE ]
it's also likely he is a neutral SK whose goal is to be the last man standing, so he isn't known to the wolves.

[Nicholasp27]

every game we take forever to clear up d1 wagons and it usually bites us in the ass

let's use today to remove that doubt...i ask that vr banishes OH from the game...we can't do wagons today so we can't learn much from today...so all we can do is to learn about yesterday's result

[dazbag666]

[ QUOTE ]
I'm rereading last nights lynch...

At 9:42, Monk puts an unprompted vote on Epi (who had zero votes). At this time, Monk was tied for the lead with Nez with 4 votes. OH and Antidan both had 3 votes... Why does Monk do this???
At 9:43 & 9:45, Chuck Norris makes a "declaration" that he must get a person that isn't the two lead BW's lynched and he will get a bonus lynch. He then votes and pushes Epi.
Why Epi? OH and Antidan are sitting in 3rd place, one vote off from the lead!

Both, the Monk move to vote Epi and the Chuck Norris move to use a clearly bogus power does not make sense!

Two possible thoughts:
1. Epi is a peeked wolf and Chuck/Monk masons tried to rally a BW on him
2. Epi is a villager and Chuck/Monk are Evil masons that tried to get him lynched with some FPS/Mishmash power play.

Epi's role claim at 9:57 that he was the Angel seemed legit to me, so I'm leaning option #2...

[/ QUOTE ]

i think its very unlikey epi is an angel, what he did last night was role claim the angel so he could survive as there were only a few minutes until night and there were mounting votes against him, i think its obvoius he is a villager though, just not the angel.

[Our House]

[ QUOTE ]
every game we take forever to clear up d1 wagons and it usually bites us in the ass

let's use today to remove that doubt...i ask that vr banishes OH from the game...we can't do wagons today so we can't learn much from today...so all we can do is to learn about yesterday's result

[/ QUOTE ]
Nich,

1) I'm a village role. You probably know this already. [img]/images/graemlins/blush.gif[/img]
2) I won't talk about the ways I can die.
3) VR's action may or may not affect me.
4) I already said that I wish Nez didn't lose the coin toss to me.

[VoraciousReader]

[ QUOTE ]
every game we take forever to clear up d1 wagons and it usually bites us in the ass

let's use today to remove that doubt...i ask that vr banishes OH from the game...we can't do wagons today so we can't learn much from today...so all we can do is to learn about yesterday's result

[/ QUOTE ]

Citizen nichp,

Given that yesterday ended in a coinflip, how informative do you expect "clearing up" the wagon to be?

Followup question: wouldn't it be more informative to kill antidan?

[Our House]

Let's talk about the weirdo actions from late yesterday. ScottNorris and his fukked up power claim. Books's vote campaign and his last minute supporting voters. EskiMonk and his strong Nez defense. Very late OH jumpers.

BTW, Eskimo was involved in like everything that happened yesterday, and now he's silenced. Dunno WTF that means aside from Eskimo != villager.

[Our House]

[ QUOTE ]
Followup question: wouldn't it be more informative to kill antidan?

[/ QUOTE ]
I know you wanted him badly yesterday, but he's been very villagey to me and a lot of others. Plus, do you really think it's a good idea to kill a silenced player? Especially since Mark made the point earlier about how wolves will sometimes silence one night, then kill the next night. Saving wolves the trouble of making a kill would be horrendous.

[Nicholasp27]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
every game we take forever to clear up d1 wagons and it usually bites us in the ass

let's use today to remove that doubt...i ask that vr banishes OH from the game...we can't do wagons today so we can't learn much from today...so all we can do is to learn about yesterday's result

[/ QUOTE ]

Citizen nichp,

Given that yesterday ended in a coinflip, how informative do you expect "clearing up" the wagon to be?

Followup question: wouldn't it be more informative to kill antidan?

[/ QUOTE ]

if oh is a wolf, then obv we nail another wolf and we can use the data to find some more suspects

if oh is a villager, then we see how him/nez got pushed to the forefront and we use that data to find some more suspects

[RoundTower]

who did the wolves target last night? Probably Herbie, Zurvan, or whoever the angel protected. Otherwise someone would be dead. I know there are all kinds of other possible interactions of powers, but this is the simplest explanation.

We already have one dead angel, so it's likely there's only one left. Epi, if you are the angel, who did you protect last night?

[DustinG]

hey.

I had started writing a long post last night but it didn't get very far.

1) Its pretty ridiculous that Books couldn't get the votes he needed, especially since he'd been talking about it since his first post. I'm almost %100 going to miss night again tonight, and likely I'll be voting for him.

2) I think MarkK is a wolf based off one of the posts I saw yesterday/ some of the shady stuff from the day before. Its was ridiculous to call Luckay villagery and Books wolfy.

3) VR is a villager.
4) I dont understand how Eskimo almost got lynched yesterday.
5) I have little opinion of OH. In BobO's game I thought he made wolfier posts than I've seen from him here, but im not calling him a villager either.

I'm here until like 9:20

books