LOTR: The Two Towers (GAME THREAD)

[GetThere1Time]

[ QUOTE ]
FMX, what's your opinion on luckay as it stands right now?

[/ QUOTE ]

[Nez477]

[ QUOTE ]
I strongly believe that Durron is a villager. His tone and defense are all villager Durron. Admittedly, I have never seen wolf Durron, and that shoots a big hole in my defense of him; however, the way that the bandwagon on him appeared yesterday was phenomenally bad. The votes on Durron at least have a reason today, since Durron was a Stephen H voter; however, you can't fault him for his one vote, can you? Traz was the main person who gathered a lot of votes for Stephen initially. Isn't Traz "never" wrong on these things? And duh, Durron voting for Stephen H doesn't "clear" him, but can't he just be a wrong villager? GT1T read me incorrectly in the Tsuibe Hakanirue (the Japanese Kumubou game, whatever) when I was playing "my villager game". He was a wolf. GT1T is reading Durron incorrectly here. Durron has exhibited several "Durron-specific" villager tells, which GT1T should be all too familiar with. I can't get over how GT1T in particular is reading Durron so incorrectly.

Lynch GetThere1Time

[/ QUOTE ]

Luckay's first two posts suck. Why does he start the day like this? As a villager or a wolf, either one this really doesn't make sense to me? Talk about a forced, nothing resembling a logical but please listen to me because I'm super serial at this game please type post.

[GetThere1Time]

wow 15 minutes even. not a peep.

[Voj]

Huh, I'm really split between Luckay and fmxda..
Luckay's kind of different in the last hour when he's wolf (could be metagaming too) and well there were a few posts not about shelob where I found fmxda wolfish.
However, we could easily be on two villagers bandwagons (*sigh* two games out of three are like that nowadays) or two wolf bandwagons (am I overoptimistic ?)
Go for :

vote fmxda

[Nez477]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Neil Stevens

I think Durron's actions last night were consistent with a villager's.

[/ QUOTE ]

Why did you come in and vote Stephen right before nightfall?

[/ QUOTE ]
Because I thought Stephen was a wolf.

And because I realized leaving my vote on some meaningless person would give Shelob cover.

[/ QUOTE ]

This, FMXDA, each time I read it, pretty much puts you over the top. I mean, you REALLY considered the Shelob aspect last night when you voted Stephen? Or is it something that was discussed in the game thread d1?

[/ QUOTE ]

[/ QUOTE ]

It was?

[GetThere1Time]

christ Voj you're always one wolfy bastard

[fmxda]

I think Luckay is likely village. But I base this mostly on the dead air dead villager tell and his tone.

I haven't reread him.

However he is a much better vote than me

[Voj]

*sigh* just reread last fmxda's post.

vote Luckay

I am really afraid we're wagonning two villagers. Shall prolly lynch durron quickly if Luckay turns village.

[Nez477]

Well, it's 15 till, I can't keep quoting posts.

I simply like Durron more than the other two.

Sorry if this screws things up, I just think FMXDA has made a good enough argument.

[sighing]

[ 0 ] aaronk voted for Durron
[ 0 ] amplify voted for Durron
[ 0 ] dmk voted for Nichp
[ 5 ] Durron voted for Jeremy
[ 0 ] FCBL voted for Luckay
[ 6 ] fmxda voted for Luckay
[ 0 ] FortFun voted for Luckay
[ 0 ] GT1T voted for Durron
[ 0 ] HerbieGRD voted for fmxda
[ 1 ] Jeremy voted for Nez477
[ 0 ] Kumu voted for Luckay
[ 10 ] Luckay voted for fmxda
[ 0 ] Mark_K voted for fmxda
[ 0 ] Neil Stevens voted for fmxda
[ 1 ] Nez477 voted for Durron
[ 1 ] Nichp voted for TFG
[ 0 ] Soah voted for Luckay
[ 1 ] TFG voted for fmxda
[ 0 ] Thebram voted for Durron
[ 0 ] traz voted for fmxda
[ 0 ] Voj voted for Luckay
[ 0 ] VR voted for Luckay
[ 0 ] wdcbooks voted for Luckay
[ 0 ] xoom voted for Luckay
[ 0 ] Xorbie
[ 0 ] Zurvan voted for Luckay