Werewolf: Pogglesworth - GAME THREAD!

[Fishmonger]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I am not voting Luckay because if he was a wolf I think he would see that what he did was a terrible play. He just isn't that dumb. When I mentioned the idea I knew it couldn't do any harm and I hoped the wolves would reveal themselves, but I thought there was only a slim chance.

What would have happened if KM was one of the three martyrs? He is screwed there as well. It just makes so much more sense to do as a villager. I will admit that it was only chance that it wasn't me who made the same claim adds to my sympathy.

[/ QUOTE ]
Ok, I give up. Maybe I'm too dumb for this game but what exactly is it that makes this play by luckay any good?
I honestly don't get it. I don't see it as something positive no matter if he is a wolf or a villager.

[/ QUOTE ]

For the sake of argument.

If he's a wolf, they trade a wolf who is already coming under pressure for an unknown.

If he's a villager, and the outcast picks him, the wolves lose a potential extra player, and Luckay just cleared himself if we believe that the outcast picked him.

Being believeable is quite important, especially if you're doing it as a villager. That's why it's a better move from a player like books than one like Luckay.

[clowntable]

Exactly luckay is not belivable at all. And if I'm on the wolf team I prefer a wolf with some suspicion that can usually weasle out of it to a confirmed wolf. Especially if the outcast is unlikely to even belive he's a wolf.

Oh well let's end this discussion and find the other wolves.

[kyro]

[ QUOTE ]


Oh well let's end this discussion and find the other wolves.

[/ QUOTE ]

Brilliant!

Couple hazy thoughts.

Every time kbar posts I want to lynch him.

I must be the only person right now that doesn't think MDoran is a clear villager. He is bothering me right now, and I see I'm alone.

I have nothing even resembling a wolf list, because I think a lot depends on what we find in the next couple of days (this is an exception, not a rule), but I still think we should be lynching valenzuela realllly soon. That being said, my vote is on luckay today, because the one time I go against my rule of thumb (lynch the FPSers who claim wolf) will be the one time I get burned.

luckay

[kbar13]

Alright guys, I'm leaving work and probably won't be on again this year.

lynch luckay and have a good new year everyone

[Boiler_bd]

Updated vote count

[ 0 ] aaronk ------ luckay
[ 0 ] amplify ------ luckay
[ 0 ] bluff ------ luckay
[ 0 ] books ------ lastchance
[ 0 ] clown ------ luckay
[ 0 ] GT1T ------
[ 0 ] kbar ------ luckay
[ 0 ] kumu ------ luckay
[ 0 ] kyro ------ luckay
[ 1 ] lastchance ------ luckay
[ 12 ] Luckay ------
[ 0 ] MDoranD ------ luckay
[ 0 ] nich ------
[ 0 ] shortline ------
[ 0 ] soah ------ luckay
[ 0 ] Tokyo ------
[ 0 ] traz ------
[ 0 ] val ------ luckay
[ 0 ] VR ------
[ 0 ] xorbie ------
[ 0 ] Zurvan ------ luckay

[traz]

luckay would absolutely do it as a wolf or a villager.

Kill him. Either he's a wolf, or maybe, JUST MAYBE, he learns not to be retarded.

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
luckay would absolutely do it as a wolf or a villager.

Kill him. Either he's a wolf, or maybe, JUST MAYBE, he learns not to be retarded.

[/ QUOTE ]
This particular play is a good one, and I wish I thought of it.

Lynch Luckay cuz he's a likely wolf, don't lynch him trying to stop a correct and obvious play.

[traz]

Its not a correct play coming from luckay.

As an outcast, would you really believe luckay and choose him? Its 100% a stupid play by luckay, a less stupid play if its done by someone else.

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
As an outcast, would you really believe luckay and choose him? Its 100% a stupid play by luckay, a less stupid play if its done by someone else.

[/ QUOTE ]
Who would you have chosen as a outcast? Even if Luckay's like only 40% wolf here, he's a better bet than anyone else.

Which is why I think the play is correct...

[traz]

If I'm outcast, I don't pick luckay. Thats all I have to say.