Guitar Heroes - GAME THREAD

[Neil S]

[ QUOTE ]
But if Dustin WAS the peek, then it doesn't matter what the motive of the kill was. All that matters is that GT1T was the seer, and we hope he hinted his n0.

[/ QUOTE ]

[DustinG]

[ QUOTE ]
I doubt Soah will give us a two in one Scott. Days are starting at morning in Europe, not morning here.

[/ QUOTE ]

don't majority me please

I really would like to get my thoughts out there, and people need to post still

[dmk]

[ QUOTE ]
However using past results to determine FUTURE actions is fine. Using the seer's death to determine the next lynch is results oriented thinking that is perfectly fine.

[/ QUOTE ]

i always thought rule #1 was lynch all liars. lets say i'm 99% sure dustin was peeked. i'm 100% sure nich lied. fwiw, i think its better to lynch nich than dustin.

if nich is wolf, do you see that dustin is a bad lynch?

dustin is being much more verbose and has spewed a lot of info already today. this isn't what he typically does as a wolf.

nich is going "LOL SEER LYNCH DUSTIN WOWOWOW GOGOGO". thats about the extent of his contribution.

if we're comfortable w/ saying that at most 1 of nich/dustin are wolves, i'd much rather lynch nich

[ScottHoward v3.1]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
dmk, that trap is when it's a setup and that person ends up being villager

gt1t was SEER...it's a diff situation

[/ QUOTE ]

i don't know what to say. i disagree. you're being results-oriented and way too ...enthusiastic?

[/ QUOTE ]Being results oriented is bad when you're evaluationg PAST plays. Evaluating Nich's seer fake with the result of the vig and the seer dying, would be results oriented thinking that is bad.

However using past results to determine FUTURE actions is fine. Using the seer's death to determine the next lynch is results oriented thinking that is perfectly fine.

[/ QUOTE ]
nich did basically nothing yesterday, why was it so important he continued on that he faked?

[Neil S]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I doubt Soah will give us a two in one Scott. Days are starting at morning in Europe, not morning here.

[/ QUOTE ]

don't majority me please

I really would like to get my thoughts out there, and people need to post still

[/ QUOTE ]There are no seers left. There's really no worry about letting people post. I don't care if you get majoritied, because we're probably lynching Nich tomorrow regardless of your role, unless Nich is killed tonight which I doubt.

[DustinG]

the question you guys need to be thinking about is:

who do you lynch after me and Nich are both dead villagers?

[dmk]

[ QUOTE ]
the question you guys need to be thinking about is:

who do you lynch after me and Nich are both dead villagers?

[/ QUOTE ]

chuckles obviously

[Supine]

So...are we ever gonna lynch neil?

[Neil S]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
However using past results to determine FUTURE actions is fine. Using the seer's death to determine the next lynch is results oriented thinking that is perfectly fine.

[/ QUOTE ]

i always thought rule #1 was lynch all liars. lets say i'm 99% sure dustin was peeked. i'm 100% sure nich lied. fwiw, i think its better to lynch nich than dustin.

if nich is wolf, do you see that dustin is a bad lynch?

dustin is being much more verbose and has spewed a lot of info already today. this isn't what he typically does as a wolf.

nich is going "LOL SEER LYNCH DUSTIN WOWOWOW GOGOGO". thats about the extent of his contribution.

if we're comfortable w/ saying that at most 1 of nich/dustin are wolves, i'd much rather lynch nich

[/ QUOTE ]FCBL's priority one was lynch wolves, as in confirmed wolves. Lynching unhelpful people (such as liars) was a lower priority.

I have no idea why we'd say only one of nich and dustin are wolves, though, and even if we were to say that, we have to pick the one the SEER hinted first... sheesh.

I'm glad I locked my vote.

[dmk]

[ QUOTE ]
I don't care if you get majoritied, because we're probably lynching Nich tomorrow regardless of your role

[/ QUOTE ]

strongly disagree. if dustin is wolf, nich would be suicidal to push dustin today as a wolf as well. it'd be far more +EV for nich to just come in going "LOL TRIXED U SUCKAS"