Malloreon II: Return of the Rivan King GAME THREAD

[Boiler_bd]

[ QUOTE ]
Considering the position the village is in at the moment lynching a generic evil is obviously better than lynching a villager but WAY worse than lynching a power evil (and may be worse than lynching Toth, I haven't quite figured that one out yet - I think it's close). Whether you agree with me or not thats why I want to lynch FCBL instead of Chuckles

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree witht the concept 300%. Lynching Naradas would be huge. If they figure out who the child of light is he will have the equivalent of 5 votes. 5!!!!!. I think the reasoning that FCBL is a "power evil" is flawed though.

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Considering the position the village is in at the moment lynching a generic evil is obviously better than lynching a villager but WAY worse than lynching a power evil (and may be worse than lynching Toth, I haven't quite figured that one out yet - I think it's close). Whether you agree with me or not thats why I want to lynch FCBL instead of Chuckles

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree witht the concept 300%. Lynching Naradas would be huge. If they figure out who the child of light is he will have the equivalent of 5 votes. 5!!!!!. I think the reasoning that FCBL is a "power evil" is flawed though.

[/ QUOTE ]
Basically my logic for this comes down to the fact that he is somehow, some way still alive and has never even had any real heat on him at the end of the day. I find the thought that this could be the case if he was a villager to be completely inconceivable. Same for him being a generic evil - the evils would have thrown him under the bus a while back. The most logical explanation is that someone (evils, neutrals, or both) want to keep him alive.

[KyrosMother]

Well, if he is being protected, the three that have never voted for him over the past 3 days are: Boiler, GT, and Luckay. Every other unconfirmed has been on his badnwagon at least once.

[Boiler_bd]

[ QUOTE ]

Basically my logic for this comes down to the fact that he is somehow, some way still alive and has never even had any real heat on him at the end of the day. I find the thought that this could be the case if he was a villager to be completely inconceivable. Same for him being a generic evil - the evils would have thrown him under the bus a while back. The most logical explanation is that someone (evils, neutrals, or both) want to keep him alive.

[/ QUOTE ]

You should read AS9 where clown was almost lynched a whole bunch of times and turned up villager.

[GetThere1Time]

It's always a good day for a chuckwagon

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

Basically my logic for this comes down to the fact that he is somehow, some way still alive and has never even had any real heat on him at the end of the day. I find the thought that this could be the case if he was a villager to be completely inconceivable. Same for him being a generic evil - the evils would have thrown him under the bus a while back. The most logical explanation is that someone (evils, neutrals, or both) want to keep him alive.

[/ QUOTE ]

You should read AS9 where clown was almost lynched a whole bunch of times and turned up villager.

[/ QUOTE ]
AS9 I assume means no special powers right? The dynamics of a game without special powers is completely different in that regard. If there weren't any special powers I would say it is probably more likely he is a villager despite all the evidence to the contrary. The existence of power evils and Toth make the comparison fall apart.

[HerbieGRD]

I can see that it isn't going to matter today - Chuck is going down and will probably turn up as an unpowered evil. I will probably leave my vote on FCBL in protest unless it is needed to lynch Chuck

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
Well, if he is being protected, the three that have never voted for him over the past 3 days are: Boiler, GT, and Luckay. Every other unconfirmed has been on his badnwagon at least once.

[/ QUOTE ]
This is interesting - I will have to look back and see how meaningful it is but it is interesting nonetheless

[Boiler_bd]

The vote power between village and non village is tied right now and you want to make a "protest" vote? Please dont.

Even if FCBL somehow turned up Naradas the primary reason he doesn't get lynched is because we the village chose not to. The neutrals probably dont know his identity and there are only 3 other evils out of what 20 village votes on average?

[KyrosMother]

Herbie,

Please note, I only took the voting for the last few hours of the day for the last 3 days. Those times were all that I thought were significant.

I think a lot of what you are saying makes sense. Unfortunately, the hardest think in this game has been getting the village together on anything...and unless <u>every villager</u> agrees to go with FCBL, we probably can't lynch him.

I will leave my vote there until 5pm, but unless the village shows a huge shift towards FCBL, we're sort of tough out of luck.

GT - do you have any other suspects but Chuck? Any at all?