(NC) post on tone - Page 2

the machine · #1 11-25-2007, 09:57 PM

[ QUOTE ]
What I hate is when someone posts a hand ABOUT A RIVER ACTION or TURN ACTION (get what I'm saying?) and everyone bitches about folding pf instead.

I think some people here don't realize that between 17/15 and 29/24 there are a lot of different pf actions. Some people open QJo UTG, others fold it on the button. Nothing pisses me off more then when people are trying to impose their pf style on me and my hand posts, when I didn't ask for it.

[/ QUOTE ]

this is why im ignored, lol.

maybe someone will repost this so he can see, but regardless of what you are asking for you might still get responses that are geared towards other streets as well. people are trying to offer you their responses for you to make the most +EV play in the long run. maybe a pf play has put you in this tough situation that in the long run could be avoided, by either folding, 4b, cold calling preflop. if you dont like the response then dont listen to it.

but your point has nothing to do with the general tone in alot of the posts recently which is what i was addressing

AllIn3High · #2 11-25-2007, 09:08 PM

[ QUOTE ]
back in the good old days when the 2p2 community was small, people didnt have 10 accounts 9 gimmick accounts, people who signed up didnt sign up to just post in BBV and B4L, we suddenly had a huge influx of people sign up due to the huge poker craze.

SSNL ranged from 2NL to 200NL. with all the new players coming in SSNL was the most trafficked site on 2p2. all of the sudden it got out of hand. everyone was so quick to jump down someones throat about hands and the tone of tons of peoples post were very crass and unhelpful to the community as a whole. we then had the split between uNL and SSNL and mods made it an effort to make sure everyone was respectful and brought meaning to their posts in the strat forums instead of just flaming someone for not being as intellectually brilliant as them when it comes to poker.

Ive noticed that this tone is coming back in so many different threads and it seems like a lot of these threads are filled with useless posts that serve no function other then raising someones post count.

here is a link incase you havent seen it or read it

posting guidelines

and incase youre too lazy to read it ill cut and paste a few blurbs out of it for you.

--flaming. Not allowed. Good natured ribbing amongst known posters is, of course, OK.

TIPS FOR RESPONDING IN HAND THREADS

--Be kind.
--Include the reasoning of your analysis, even if it's brief.

Bad: Raise more pf.
Good: Your hand plays best heads-up, but your preflop raise was too small to get the job done. Try raising to $6 instead of $3.

Bad: Push river.
Good: Pooosh. Villian likes his hand. You have the second nuts. If he's got quads, oh well.

Bad: You're too stupid to play SSNL. Try checkers instead.
Good: Bad on every street. 1/4-pot flop bet was purposeless, turn call was horrible given your odds, then you suckout on the river and get no value.

Bad: You can't call this turn.
Good: You can't call this turn because your opponent is WAY to passive to start betting here without the flush, and you don't have the odds to chase anymore.

Bad: Raise the flop.
Good: Raise the flop to $18 to protect your hand.

also so many posts are just hands, no read, no rhyme or reason to why you played a hand or why you made an odd play with a hand. include this to make it easier for everyone when you post.

but in general the attitude and tone of many responses in this forum are becoming ridiculous. i hope the mods start enforcing there rules because this is a place of learning. dont just tell a person hes a moron, explain to him why he is a moron.

[/ QUOTE ]

Just to add some content to this post besides just quoting so manupod can read it:

http://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/showfl...=0#Post13113706

That's the kind of threads that could be avoided. Not ripping the OP, but that threads not gonna generate any interesting responses at all.

Jay Riall · #3 11-25-2007, 09:14 PM

[ QUOTE ]
Bad: Raise more pf.
Good: Your hand plays best heads-up, but your preflop raise was too small to get the job done. Try raising to $6 instead of $3.

[/ QUOTE ]

Personally, I won't post in SSNL if I have to make posts like this where people need spoon feeding really obvious points.

the machine · #4 11-25-2007, 09:19 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Bad: Raise more pf.
Good: Your hand plays best heads-up, but your preflop raise was too small to get the job done. Try raising to $6 instead of $3.

[/ QUOTE ]

Personally, I won't post in SSNL if I have to make posts like this where people need spoon feeding really obvious points.

[/ QUOTE ]

thats the problem jay, its not obvious to everyone. either dont post or post something insightful. so i think thats a good thing if you decide not to post on something you think is obvious rather then make a bad post.

aside from those types of posts, ie raise, fold, bet more, i was addressing more on peoples tone lately. its like everyone is on their period around here