Top set should fold?

[Nick C]

All right, this has turned into a somewhat self-congratulatory "you're nuts to fold" thread, and I agree that calling is the play given Villain's stats.

But I am going to say that if he were looser preflop (and perhaps less aggressive postflop too), I don't think it would be so clear.

Part of the problem is that there just aren't very many TsXh hands available.