Should God Make Sense?

[Sephus]

someone might object to a religious definition of god because it doesn't "make sense." an apologist will often say "why should the mind of god have to make sense to your puny human brain?"

my question is, what makes an (omnipotent) god who wants people to believe things that are true distinguishable from a god who wants people to believe things that are false?

don't we have to fall back on "the more straightforward god makes more sense to us"? we certainly can't tell by looking at the "real" evidence, because god created it all.