Question about a $1-2 NL black hole player

[PAUL-IN]

I've got a home game where there's one player, who i think we all agree is a good player, but also VERY lucky. it's a $1-2 game and usually he cashes for about $200-400.

Questions is this: everyone gets pissed off that he 'locks it down' when he's up and tightens up like a drum and never plays anything except AA KK QQ AK. people are arguing to ban him or impose rules like where he HAS to see 50% of flops, etc...

what to tell the ones who demand these rules of him?

i have an opinion but would like to hear your side. Thanks.