For the NY City food OOT people.

[uberoval]

My girlfriend and I will be in the city next friday, saturday and sunday. I want to take her to a nice place on saturday night. I know i'll need to make a reservation today or tomorrow so I am asking for some descent suggestions. I don't want to spend more than $300 total as hopefully the Sabre/Rangers will go to a game 6 and i'll need extra funds for 2 tickets to that game. Doesn't need to be a mainstream, trendy place. Almost rather go to a killer unknown but great establishment.