Offical Down to 6 We Go AI Thread

[GoRedBirds]

[ QUOTE ]
No matter who wins this year, they will be considered the worst idol yet, right?

[/ QUOTE ]
If you take all of the singers as a whole, this is the worst batch I've seen since I've been watching the show. Individually, Melinda may be the most talented singer I've ever seen on the show. If she wins, it will be interesting to see how she sells herself, but I will guarantee a market for her. She's just too damn good.

The jury's still out on Jordin for me, but if she won she wouldn't match up too poorly at all against Taylor or Ruben imo (and probably Fantasia, although I didn't really watch that season). Blake is interesting from a marketing standpoint... so I don't know how he'd fare against past winners.

If any of the others win, then yes. Chris, Lakisha or Phil would easily be the worst idol yet.