Best athlete in a team sport

[jstnrgrs]

I tried to ask this question several months ago with baseball, but the issue of positions made it difficult. So I am going to try with volleyball (indoor, 6v6, no subs, must rotate, etc).

Suppose there are 12 volleyball players, and we want to devise a competition that will rank them reasonably. Would the following be a good system:

1) randomly divide the players into two teams of 6.

2) play a game between these two teams

3) assign one point to each player on the winning team

4) repeat steps 1 through 3 many times

5) rank the players by how many points they have.