Stars v. Tilt: Do the fish outweigh the bonuses?

[Oranzith]

Stars Pro's assuming they stay in the market:
FISH FISH FISH
Nice Software (love waffle card)
FPP + Nice Store
Reload Bonuses
$50 first deposit bonus
RESIZABLE TABLES

FTP:
27% RB
$600 first deposit bonus
Nice Software (my skins make it look nicer than Stars w/ waffle cards)
FPP - crappy store (although claims to be getting better)
No resizable tables (not yet anyway)
Large number of fish growing consistently


What it seems to boil down to is whether 550 dollars in bonus + 27% RB + crappy FPP that might get bette > = < Stars FISH + FPP


I am leaning towards Stars. I am holding off on creating anything at either site until Stars releases its statement as I am sure MANY people are doing, and are wondering the same thing I am concerning these two leading sites.