MISH-MASH III: THE MISHMASHENING

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]
Zruvan no, my idea is correct. If you are evil and see that a non evil is abotu to be lynched and then he comes out as a villager and gives the village a "2nd chance" to get it right, that is obviously -EV for evil.

[/ QUOTE ]

While I see your point, I'm not sure it's correct.

Let's assume we find 2 candidates, and put votes on them. The leading vote getter drinks the potion, is a villager, and dies. We lynch our second option. He's a villager. We've lost 2 villagers, and then however many die or whatever at night.

Best case scenario, we kill off Jekyll/Hyde. Worst case scenario, we lose an extra villager. Thats +EV for evil, as they're one step closer to winning. As it is, the first 4 days, we can lose 2 villagers to the bad guy, 1 to J/H, 1 to the vigilante, and who knows what the Pumpkin will do. Throw in an extra death for the potential lynchee, that's 5 dead people.

Actually, after thinking about it, I'm positive this is a terrible idea.

In addition, if it is J/H, you would want to lynch a confirmed villager because they lived!