|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
How Bout Enumerating The Flawed Hands In Colin\'s Book
I was thinking it would be helpful if there was a consensus among you pros out there as to which of the sample hands are definitely wrong, in your combined opinion, as far as his answer is concerned. (Not his reasoning.) I'm not talking about debatable answers or those which "it depends". I'm talking about the ones where you would all agree his answer is incorrect. Preliminary reviews make me think there a few such questions. I, and I'm sure Mason and Colin, would like to know which ones they are.
|
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Re: How Bout Enumerating The Flawed Hands In Colin\'s Book
How bout posting up pics of hot scrippaz first?
TIME TO PAY YOUR STTF DUES DAVID! Yugoslav |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Re: How Bout Enumerating The Flawed Hands In Colin\'s Book
David,
Here's a pair of hands that bothered me. Hands 2 and 6 of Appendix F are essentially the same hand, yet Collin must be using two vastly different ranges on the same players to justify Hand 2 as an any-two-card push and Hand 6 as an "any decent hand" push. For what it's worth, I like the Hand 6 analysis much better, but that could be a result of different game conditions. Apparently Collin was crushing the old Party 216s when I was still 1-tabling $22 limit O8 SNGs for fun on Saturday nights. How much am I allowed to post without infringing on copyrights? If it's OK with the law-talking-guys, I think those two hands would make for good discussion. Slim |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Re: How Bout Enumerating The Flawed Hands In Colin\'s Book
For now, I just want to see a list from several good players and then cull that down to those where almost all agree the answer is wrong. (I'd expect that to be five or fewere.) Discussion of individual problems are for other threads. This thread is soley to develop that list.
|
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Re: How Bout Enumerating The Flawed Hands In Colin\'s Book
This thread is an obvious ploy to get us to buy the book.
|
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Re: How Bout Enumerating The Flawed Hands In Colin\'s Book
[ QUOTE ]
This thread is an obvious ploy to get us to buy the book. [/ QUOTE ] Your chips have gone in and you've been called. Sklansky says, show your cards. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Re: How Bout Enumerating The Flawed Hands In Colin\'s Book
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ] This thread is an obvious ploy to get us to buy the book. [/ QUOTE ] Your chips have gone in and you've been called. Sklansky says, show your cards. [/ QUOTE ] our credit cards? you probably mean that but otherwise i dont get it |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Re: How Bout Enumerating The Flawed Hands In Colin\'s Book
[ QUOTE ]
For now, I just want to see a list from several good players and then cull that down to those where almost all agree the answer is wrong. (I'd expect that to be five or fewere.) Discussion of individual problems are for other threads. This thread is soley to develop that list. [/ QUOTE ] david. most very good players havent purchased the book. they may or may not be in the future, but probably not. perhaps this thread should wait a few weeks/months until more sng players have purchased it? otherwise you probably wont get what you are looking for. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Re: How Bout Enumerating The Flawed Hands In Colin\'s Book
what he is looking for is clearly worth a few copies. If he really want's this info (expert advice/analysis) he should send the top pro's free copies and kindly ask for their input. Truth is, I find it increadable they didnt do this before publishing as part of the proofreading/editing process.
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Re: How Bout Enumerating The Flawed Hands In Colin\'s Book
At least post the hands we are supposed to be discussing!
|
|
|