JTs vs NIT & donk in 3way flop, is this good?

[Kyuss]

$2/4

SB is a huge donk 58/30 or something
Villain/UTG $227 25.8/3.2/0.59 over 90 hands, VERY PASSIVE
Hero/BU $158 My image is TAG slightly loose, low stack due to suckout, my stats on the table at the time 26/14

Dealt to Hero [T[img]/images/graemlins/spade.gif[/img] J[img]/images/graemlins/spade.gif[/img]]
UTG calls, 2 folds, Hero raises to $16, SB calls, BB folds, UTG calls.

FLOP ($52) [Q[img]/images/graemlins/spade.gif[/img] J[img]/images/graemlins/diamond.gif[/img] 5[img]/images/graemlins/spade.gif[/img]]
SB checks, UTG bets $48, <font color="red">Hero raises to $142 (all-in)</font>

[illuminati]

lol

[Andynan]

you pretty much have odds to call againts anything but a set and even then its close. Call and suckout

[FireStorm]

I can't determine which is worse, the OP or the response that indicates that CALLING is good here.

Reload before the hand please, $158 is worthless is 2/4 NL and makes hands like these -EV because you can't get paid when you flop big.

As played, there's not really a question here. You have a nothing stack, a solid pot, and the best possible non-complete-hand flop. Obviously your shove here is fine.

[KeanuReaver]

i don't even know whats going on

[Kyuss]

Please, criticizing short stack when I made it clear that it's not how I usually play is just... whatever. I got sucked out the hand before so I thought this a good flop to stick it in, nothing wrong with that. Sometimes you don't get to reload in time, doesn't mean it warrants criticism. You can say it doesn't deserve a thread(maybe), but no need to say I'm bad.

[Rampage_Jackson]

FIST PUMP.

[mrcoughman]

Once you get to the flop the way you did the push is sooo standard

[FireStorm]

Well, if you wound up playing this hand shortstacked, that's fine, you are correct that not everyone has to be a maniacal nit reloader every single hand they dip a cent below the $400 mark. However, $158 obviously isn't advisable.

IF it's the case that you play the hand with $158, that's fine, but this then lacks any relevance as a question. You are 40 BB's deep and flop mid pair and a four flush in a sizable pot, I can't imagine doing anything but shoving.

[Kyuss]

Yeah as I can see after making the post it's an obvious shove, my play was standard lol.