[kokiri]

[ QUOTE ]
So we can,
a)lynch books. if he's telling the truth, lynch Nich tomorrow
b)lynch books. if he's lying, don't lynch Nich tomorrow
c)lynch Nich. if he's VP, don't lynch books tomorrow
d)lynch Nich. if he's not VP lynch books tomorrow
e)lynch somebody no Nich or books

Is there anything that makes (a) superior or inferior to (d), same question for (b) and (c).

The only thing I can think of is that books wouldn't make this up as a villager, but he could be telling the truth as a wolf to clear either him or Nich. The later being pretty risky this early with so many unknown roles however with CinCity and antidan gone this would be far less risky.

IMO, I'd like to error towards not lynching books and go after somebody that not books/nich.

[/ QUOTE ]

until nich claims to be a power villager, as books is doing, i don't see how a/b can be > than c/d because a risks nailing another power villager.